August 2nd, 2024

What I learned about a plastic-free life

An NPR producer documented her week-long challenge to eliminate single-use plastics, revealing difficulties in sourcing food, high costs of alternatives, and the need for systemic changes to reduce plastic use.

Read original articleLink Icon
What I learned about a plastic-free life

An NPR producer undertook a week-long challenge to eliminate single-use plastics from her life, inspired by the Plastic Free July movement. She aimed to understand the difficulties of living without plastic and shared her experiences and tips. The challenge involved avoiding online shopping and food delivery, using reusable containers, and planning meals to prevent impulsive purchases. Despite her efforts, she still generated around 102 pieces of plastic waste from existing food and toiletries.

The producer faced significant challenges, particularly in sourcing food, as most items are packaged in plastic. She resorted to making meals from scratch, which was time-consuming but also a learning experience about local food systems. While she successfully avoided many single-use plastics, she encountered obstacles, such as grocery store staff not being familiar with using personal containers.

In terms of toiletries, she found that plastic-free alternatives were often more expensive and harder to find. The week also taught her about composting, revealing that not all biodegradable items are compostable. Ultimately, she concluded that going completely plastic-free is nearly impossible, as some necessary ingredients still come in plastic packaging. The experience highlighted the complexities of reducing plastic use and emphasized that while individual efforts are valuable, systemic changes are also needed to address the plastic problem effectively.

Link Icon 8 comments
By @johnklos - 7 months
It's practically impossible to avoid plastic without great effort. I think even if we collectively don't do much towards that goal, each of us should think about it while we go about our daily lives.

For instance, there are times where the choice is wholly ours. Eggs, for instance, often come in plastic or cardboard, so aside from taking a few extra seconds to consider the kind of eggs we want, that's easy. If we want yogurt, though, we basically have little choice beyond considering the packaging that wastes the least plastic.

But there's still so much we can do. When we know that a store puts plastic utensils in an order without asking, and/or gives us our purchase in a plastic bag, it's simple to ask them for neither. It's also simple to carry a reusable bag or two, or a travel mug, et cetera.

Spending just a little energy can easily reduce default plastic use quite a lot. This story is a good reminder that perfect should never be the enemy of good, so at very least we should try where we can.

By @kvark - 7 months
It’s a bit ridiculous that we’ve built a system to motivate change by distributing money, and that system fails flat when it comes to plastic use. In a healthy society, avoiding plastic would be both cheaper and more convenient.
By @siliconc0w - 7 months
If we charged companies the true cost of plastics we'd have a perfectly adequate biodegradable alternatives by now
By @tjpnz - 7 months
Having toddlers I've thrown out multiple larger plastic items over the years - think things like diaper bins and stools. I now look towards the plastic slide they've since grown out of and feel only despair. For some items there are opportunities for donation, but everything else gets walked down to our building's trash room and I fucking hate it. Companies who bring such items into the world should bear some of the responsibility for their disposal and certainly shouldn't get to walk away as they currently do.
By @robertclaus - 7 months
We have done a lot of work trying to price the societal cost of carbon emissions into the cost of doing business... Why haven't we done the same with things like plastic waste?
By @kkfx - 7 months
Few practical observations:

- plastic packaging, single use plastic stuff, tend to be mostly needed in cities and cities only. That's simply because in dense cities people keep moving from residential buildings (used less than half a day), to other buildings (offices, commerce etc, also used for less than half a day in mean), in a continuous very short-range commuting, getting continuous non-block-able ads (shop windows), so they tend to eat on the go, buy small stuff they have to carry around etc, also smaller residential emplacements demand small stock at home of anything, so more packaging;

- plastic it's not only packaging, large slice of tissues are plastics, menstruation related products are plastic, electricity cables insulation is plastic, windows joint, many plumbing materials, cars tires and many cars elements, ... are all plastic of some kind.

So to say: we can't being plastic free on scale, simply because when we was it was another era with less humans on earth and much more resources needed for personal wellbeing even if we have had much less back then. Yes, we can have natural fiber dresses, BUT not for anyone, we can make cars without plastics (almost) but they would be much more expensive and energy consuming and so on.

What we can do is AVOIDING living in dense cities, witch is appropriate for many reasons, also to reduce single use plastics. Cities are NOT green at all despite finance capitalism propaganda.

By @userbinator - 7 months
tl;dr: live like the (early) 19th century.

It's perplexing to see people jump on this stupid "anti-plastic" mentality bandwagon when they probably owe their entire existence to plastics and other advances in material sciences. Trying to reverse these changes will only lead to societal collapse, as somewhat hinted at in the article.

Everything will get recycled eventually, and the majority of plastics are inert --- which is why they're used in the first place. People in the future will surely find a way to use what's in landfills again.

Plus, I had to haul a heavy tote bag of containers everywhere.

Now you know why plastic replaced glass containers in a majority of applications --- and if you're worried about carbon emissions from shipping, all that extra weight and volume should make you ponder.

By @constantcrying - 7 months
Plastics certainly is one of the most useful materials known to humans. It is incredibly versatile and cheap.

Any area of life has been significantly effected by the use of plastics as a material. I think articles like this are laughable, the plastic use of individuals in their daily lives is just a tiny, tiny peak of the iceberg. Beneath there sits an industrial society which could not exist without it. No, you can not live "plastic free".

The first and most important questions these people have to ask is: how do you make anything without plastics?