August 9th, 2024

23-Floor Manhattan Office Building Just Sold at a 97.5% Discount

The 23-story Manhattan office building sold for $8.5 million, a 97.5% drop from its 2006 price, highlighting the pandemic's impact on office demand and ongoing market struggles.

Read original articleLink Icon
23-Floor Manhattan Office Building Just Sold at a 97.5% Discount

The 23-story office building at 135 West 50th Street in Manhattan has been sold for $8.5 million, a staggering 97.5% discount from its 2006 sale price of $332 million. The building, which is currently only 35% occupied, reflects the significant impact of the pandemic on New York City's office market, where many properties have seen steep declines in value. The sale occurred through an online auction after previous attempts to sell the building for under $50 million failed. The new owner faces challenges, as the building's rental income does not cover the lease payments for the land, which is owned separately. Renovations or conversions to residential use are potential options, but both come with high costs and logistical hurdles. The building, constructed in the 1960s, has been home to various major companies but now suffers from outdated features and a less desirable location. The sale highlights the ongoing struggles of Manhattan's office sector as companies adapt to hybrid work models, leading to increased vacancies and diminished demand for traditional office spaces.

- The Manhattan office building sold for $8.5 million, down from $332 million in 2006.

- The building is only 35% occupied, reflecting the pandemic's impact on office space demand.

- The new owner faces financial challenges due to insufficient rental income to cover land lease payments.

- Renovation or conversion to residential use are potential but costly options for the new owner.

- The sale underscores the broader struggles of New York City's office market amid changing work patterns.

Link Icon 12 comments
By @dredmorbius - 2 months
What's notable here is that the discount is from a 2006 sale.

I've seen previous ~90% valuation declines but based on sales far more recent.

Chicago, 90% decline 2013 -- 2024: <https://www.chicagobusiness.com/commercial-real-estate/offic...>

San Francisco, 90% decline 2016 -- 2024: <https://sfist.com/2024/04/23/empty-office-building-at-sixth-...>

The impact of a 90% devaluation of the CMB (commercial mortgage-backed) securities market will have an immense impact on bank and investor balance sheets, which brings to mind the 2007-8 residential real estate crash and financial crisis.

Total present commercial mortgage valuation is about $3.6 trillion if I'm reading things correctly:

<https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=1rCDW>

By @unpythonic - 2 months
Here's a better article covering this situation: https://wolfstreet.com/2024/08/01/values-of-old-office-tower...

Unsurprising that a building's value goes down over time while the land on which it resides appreciates. The 97% discount is a comparison of the building price versus the building + land price, so the 97% isn't very relevant.

By @fitzroy - 2 months
It sold for $8.5 million... ..."The auction was for the building itself, not the land. That is owned by a publicly traded real estate firm, which collects a monthly lease. But the rent from the building’s current tenants is not enough to cover those monthly payments, which are set to increase every five years and do not expire until 2123."
By @TrackerFF - 2 months
The Covid upshoot was WILD. Housing real-estate exploded, commercial stagnated, now the REPE firms are squirming to brake even.
By @johnea - 2 months
Maybe this means HOPE can move back to Manhattan!

https://hope.net/

By @hleszek - 2 months
Who would buy a building like this without the land? How does it make sense?
By @shmerl - 2 months
If offices are shrinking, they can turn it into a residential building.
By @dredmorbius - 2 months
Archive / paywall: <https://archive.is/NpdIo>
By @19h - 2 months
Or maybe, just maybe, this is tax evasion?