Hilary Mantel Reviews “A Life of One's Own/An Experiment in Leisure” (1986)

Joanna Field's works, "A Life of One's Own" and "An Experiment in Leisure," are examined in a review by Hilary Mantel, highlighting Field's introspective journey through her own psyche. First published in the 1930s, these books reflect Field's earnest self-analysis as she grapples with her identity and the nature of happiness. In "A Life of One's Own," Field, a young psychologist, explores her feelings of disconnection from life and her struggle with willpower, leading her to question traditional definitions of success. She advocates for a passive approach to creativity, suggesting that relinquishing the pursuit of achievement can foster inspiration. In "An Experiment in Leisure," Field continues her exploration, contemplating the value of femininity and the tendency of some, particularly women, to derive identity from others. She critiques contemporary psychoanalytic theories and emphasizes the importance of personal mythology over societal narratives. Mantel notes that while Field's insights are profound, her self-scrutiny can lead to a sense of dissatisfaction, as she often fails to fully embrace her own mind. The review positions Field's work as both a personal and cultural exploration, revealing the complexities of human experience and the evolving understanding of identity in the context of early 20th-century thought.

- Joanna Field's works focus on self-exploration and the nature of happiness.

- "A Life of One's Own" critiques traditional definitions of success and advocates for a passive approach to creativity.

- "An Experiment in Leisure" examines femininity and the tendency to derive identity from others.

- Field's insights challenge contemporary psychoanalytic theories and emphasize personal mythology.

- The review highlights the cultural significance of Field's work in understanding identity and human experience.