August 20th, 2024

The AI photo editing era is here, and it's every person for themselves

Google's Pixel 9 enhances photo editing with AI features, allowing easy alterations. This sparks a counter-movement favoring vintage cameras, highlighting the debate over authenticity in edited images versus genuine memories.

Read original articleLink Icon
The AI photo editing era is here, and it's every person for themselves

The advent of AI photo editing is transforming how individuals capture and modify their memories, with Google's Pixel 9 set to enhance this trend. The device's Magic Editor feature allows users to remove unwanted elements from photos effortlessly, prompting a debate about the authenticity of edited images. As users experiment with AI tools, they may question whether heavily altered images still represent genuine memories. The upcoming Pixel 9 series will introduce advanced generative AI capabilities, enabling users to add or change significant aspects of their photos, such as scenery and objects, using text prompts. This shift has sparked a counter-movement, particularly among Gen Z, who are gravitating towards vintage digital cameras that embrace imperfection and a lo-fi aesthetic. This trend reflects a desire for authenticity in an age of polished digital imagery. The article suggests that while AI editing can enhance certain aspects of photography, it may also detract from the personal touch that makes memories meaningful. As technology continues to evolve, individuals will need to navigate their comfort levels with AI-enhanced photography, balancing the desire for perfection with the value of genuine, unedited moments.

- Google's Pixel 9 introduces advanced AI photo editing features.

- Users can remove and alter significant elements in their photos with ease.

- A counter-movement is emerging, favoring vintage cameras for their authenticity.

- The debate centers on the authenticity of heavily edited images versus genuine memories.

- Individuals will need to find their comfort level with AI-enhanced photography.

Link Icon 9 comments
By @illwrks - 3 months
As someone who's role involves some elements of image editing, Adobe's GenAI feature is a welcome tool... however, as someone who's read 1984 and is concerned about the future tidal wave of scams, I'm not so keen on ever a$$hole and his/her dog being enabled.
By @mkaic - 3 months
I want photos to be a record of my perception. I want them to match what I see in front of me as closely as possible. I do not care if data is mangled to make this happen — in fact, the reason I love my iPhone's camera so much is because it mangles the raw sensor data so much. Apple's computational photography pipeline is state-of-the-art, and it is designed to make photos look as close to my perception as possible. All my favorite sunset photos have all been taken on my iPhone.

I do not like these AI photo-editing features. Or rather, I do not like the use of them, and will not be using them myself. The technology itself is stunning and exciting! But it entirely defeats the purpose of taking a photo for me. If someone blinks in a group picture, I want the blink to stay. If there's some obnoxious piece of garbage in the background, I want it to stay, because the whole point is for a photo to be a representation of reality consistent with my eyesight at the time it was taken.

I truly love candid photos. I am open to computational photography and even AI processing, but it should exclusively serve the goal of making the photo more candid. I feel that the AI photo editing features being pushed out these days will only make photos less candid.

By @andirk - 3 months
Before I wrote a single line of code, I championed my abilities to add/subtract individuals from photos for family and friends, first using ClarisWorks Paint! My Samsung S22 can now do this within seconds and better. I removed a TV in front of some liquor bottles on the wall. It repeated the bottles but not even the same ones!
By @ChrisArchitect - 3 months
Related:

Procreate's anti-AI pledge attracts praise from digital creatives

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41295957

By @throw0101d - 3 months
Hopefully we'll get some rise in use of image provenance:

> The Coalition for Content Provenance and Authenticity (C2PA) addresses the prevalence of misleading information online through the development of technical standards for certifying the source and history (or provenance) of media content. C2PA is a Joint Development Foundation project, formed through an alliance between Adobe, Arm, Intel, Microsoft and Truepic.

* https://c2pa.org

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_Authenticity_Initiativ...

* 2022 Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30475137

By @lowbloodsugar - 3 months
"Like me, not everyone will have the stomach for it. In fact, some people are running in the opposite direction as fast as they can."

A tiny minority. Everyone will use this. Eventually, the system will remove the vaping "dinguses" automatically just as it automatically adjusts the exposure.

By @system2 - 3 months
As if people didn't photoshop the hell out of photos before. This "era" began 20 years ago. Look at instagram, for the last decade these techniques were applied without ai.
By @warrenmiller - 3 months