August 23rd, 2024

As cars and trucks get bigger and taller, lawmakers look to protect pedestrians

Congress is introducing the Pedestrian Protection Act to enhance pedestrian safety by establishing federal standards for vehicle hood height and visibility, addressing rising fatalities linked to larger vehicles.

Read original articleLink Icon
As cars and trucks get bigger and taller, lawmakers look to protect pedestrians

Lawmakers in Congress are set to introduce a bill aimed at enhancing pedestrian safety in response to the increasing size and weight of vehicles, which have been linked to a rise in pedestrian fatalities. The proposed legislation, known as the Pedestrian Protection Act, would establish federal standards for hood height and visibility, addressing the dangers posed by larger vehicles, particularly SUVs and trucks. Research indicates that vehicles with higher front ends are 45% more likely to cause fatalities in pedestrian accidents compared to smaller cars. Since 2009, pedestrian deaths have surged by over 75%, with larger vehicles contributing significantly to this trend. The bill's co-sponsor, Rep. Mary Gay Scanlon, emphasized the need to extend safety standards to protect pedestrians, cyclists, and other vulnerable road users. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) would be responsible for implementing these standards. Despite previous calls for improved pedestrian safety measures, advocates express concern that past proposals have lacked sufficient enforcement mechanisms. The bill reflects a growing recognition of the need to balance the popularity of larger vehicles with the safety of all road users.

- Congress is introducing the Pedestrian Protection Act to enhance safety for pedestrians.

- Larger vehicles are significantly more dangerous for pedestrians, contributing to rising fatality rates.

- The proposed legislation would set federal standards for vehicle hood height and visibility.

- The NHTSA will oversee the implementation of these new safety standards.

- Advocates are concerned about the effectiveness of past pedestrian safety proposals.

Link Icon 13 comments
By @mtalantikite - 3 months
> Over the past three decades, the average U.S. passenger vehicle has gotten about 10 inches longer, 8 inches taller and 1,000 pounds heavier, according to IIHS.

As a New Yorker I'm not often in a car, but whenever I'm stuck in traffic I think about this. If all the cars are 10 inches longer, that adds up over the course of all the cars I'm stuck behind and has a real impact on the carrying capacity of the road.

To another point of the article, I walked by an SUV the other day where the front hood was up to my shoulders. I'm pretty regular height at 6' and just thought how getting hit by that thing would probably kill me. It's like all the cars on the road are in an arms race with each other.

By @atlasunshrugged - 3 months
One thing I'm a little surprised not to see in the article is any discussion of distracted driving. While I think in the EU cars are slightly smaller on average, there are still plenty of larger vehicles on the road but relatively fewer deaths. The only thesis I have as to the potential disconnect is that in the EU there are far more stick shift operated vehicles which demand more attention and limbs to operate as compared to American vehicles which skew heavily automatic, making it much easier to doomscroll twitter or try to respond to a text.
By @groestl - 3 months
Sometimes, just for fun, I entertain the thought that speed limits in cities could be based on a vehicle's impulse.
By @russellbeattie - 3 months
It's not just pedestrians, driving a small, low car like a Miata is becoming nearly as dangerous as riding a motorcycle. Bigger vehicles simply don't see you. The only thing saving the little cars is that they're also more nimble, so when a giant truck starts moving into your lane - despite the fact that you're currently occupying it - you can maneuver quickly and stay alive. You'd be amazed at how common this experience is.
By @freeduhm - 3 months
I think it is important to also note the increase in pedestrians in general. Assuming bicycalists and scooterists (?) are considered pedestrians, there has been a big increase in there usage primarily due to lithium batteries becoming more efficient. It is understandable that there will be an increase in events involving pedestrians. Have not saying I know the answer to reducing pedestrian fatalities but the article I think failed to place the fatalities in context of the increase in scooters and bikes by people.
By @swozey - 3 months
I've seen one explode and melt to nothing but I'm surprised there hasn't been a report of a Cybertruck slicing someone (beyond fingers) in half yet.
By @bell-cot - 3 months
Start by putting a heavy-duty "Roadkill Tax" on those vehicles where the driver couldn't possibly see a pedestrian 'till his body showed up in the rear view mirror. It shouldn't be too hard to pack a few congressional committee meetings with families of their victims, to help get that passed.
By @anotherhue - 3 months
So nice to be considered. Glad that our children will be considered minority stakeholders in this.
By @vlovich123 - 3 months
Two possible paths forward:

Separate streets and roads so that roads don’t have people and people and bicycles cross across roads through skywalks or tunnels.

Wait for the cars to get bigger and taller enough that they become planes and the humans cross under that way.

By @mensetmanusman - 3 months
Self notifying technology and all around cameras and alerts can help.
By @snitzr - 3 months
When I was kid my dad had a Dodge Ram 50 which was about the size of a car and it had a four-cylinder engine with a manual transmission and no 4WD. Never had any issues hauling anything. We put a pallet of bricks in the bed and it wasn't a problem. Modern trucks are too expensive and big for no real reason other than ego and insecurity. It's blue-collar cosplay. Maybe a few people need a huge truck, but for most people a smaller truck or a van would work better.
By @carabiner - 3 months
This was all caused by the CAFE emissions standards that allow cars with bigger footprints to emit more. Nobody wants bigger fucking trucks and in the Tacoma community it's a standard refrain to bemoan just how fucking big they've gotten. They aren't compact trucks anymore. They're midsize today. Compact trucks do not exist.
By @SoftTalker - 3 months
"roadway fatalities have also climbed sharply over the past decade"

If that's true, it doesn't say much good about the effectiveness of all the safety regulations over the years that have added thousands of dollars to the price of a car.