With Power Comes Great Responsibility Platforms Want to Be Utilities (2021)
Tech giants have created user dependency through opaque account termination processes and laws favoring corporate interests. Advocates seek transparency in moderation and "information fiduciary" rules to protect consumer rights.
Read original articleTech giants have increasingly positioned themselves as indispensable utilities in our digital lives, claiming missions that emphasize connectivity and accessibility. However, their practices often lead to significant user dependency, with individuals entrusting sensitive data to these platforms. When users face account suspensions or terminations, the processes are frequently opaque and frustrating, lacking clear appeals or explanations. This situation is exacerbated by laws like the DMCA and CFAA, which have historically favored corporate interests over consumer rights, allowing companies to maintain control over user data and access. The consolidation of power among a few tech giants has created a landscape where losing access to one service can result in the loss of multiple essential services, from personal data to financial transactions. Critics argue for the need for transparency in moderation decisions and the establishment of "information fiduciary" rules that would require companies to act in the best interests of their users. Such reforms could ensure that users retain control over their data and have clear recourse in the event of account issues.
- Tech giants have become essential utilities, leading to user dependency on their platforms.
- Account termination processes are often opaque and lack adequate appeal mechanisms.
- Laws like the DMCA and CFAA have historically favored corporate interests, limiting consumer rights.
- Losing access to one service can result in the loss of multiple essential services.
- Advocates call for transparency in moderation and the establishment of "information fiduciary" rules.
Related
Tech's accountability tantrum is pathetic
Silicon Valley tech giants criticized for lack of accountability and ethical behavior. Companies like Uber, Amazon, Google, and individuals like Elon Musk prioritize innovation over laws and ethics. Resistance to oversight and lobbying against regulations noted. Importance of accountability stressed to prevent societal harm.
Our Users Deserve a Bill of Rights
The author critiques the tech industry's neglect of end users, advocating for a "User Bill of Rights" to ensure accountability and balance between innovation and stability in software development.
Computer Security Is a Political Struggle
The digital landscape is increasingly controlled by a few, leading to political struggles over technology. Cybersecurity issues reflect deeper political failures, necessitating a collective response to reclaim digital rights and security.
Apple vs. the "Free Market"
Apple's 30% App Store fee impacts creators' revenues, distorts markets, and limits competition. Its DMCA interpretation enforces restrictive device rules, raising concerns about consumer rights and smaller businesses' viability.
Why Technological Progress Is Now Reversing
The article discusses the disconnect between technological advancement and societal benefit, highlighting issues like user exploitation, lack of accountability, and the need for reevaluating technology's societal role.
This.
There are lots of laws and court rulings about customer privacy, indecent content, and right-to-repair. I haven't heard about any commission or legislature working on a "customer bill of rights" but maybe there is one? If not, there should be.
A clear and fair appeal process for any company exceeding a certain size, with spelled-out procedures, complete with names and phone numbers of the responsible people, seems like a reasonable thing to mandate. As a rule the market should be given a chance to work, but it seems pretty clear that it's failed here. That thread this week about Chase Bank is the poster child.
"You have violated our policies" without any details on what policies you violated, or how, should someday be just a horrible memory of the bad old days.
Related
Tech's accountability tantrum is pathetic
Silicon Valley tech giants criticized for lack of accountability and ethical behavior. Companies like Uber, Amazon, Google, and individuals like Elon Musk prioritize innovation over laws and ethics. Resistance to oversight and lobbying against regulations noted. Importance of accountability stressed to prevent societal harm.
Our Users Deserve a Bill of Rights
The author critiques the tech industry's neglect of end users, advocating for a "User Bill of Rights" to ensure accountability and balance between innovation and stability in software development.
Computer Security Is a Political Struggle
The digital landscape is increasingly controlled by a few, leading to political struggles over technology. Cybersecurity issues reflect deeper political failures, necessitating a collective response to reclaim digital rights and security.
Apple vs. the "Free Market"
Apple's 30% App Store fee impacts creators' revenues, distorts markets, and limits competition. Its DMCA interpretation enforces restrictive device rules, raising concerns about consumer rights and smaller businesses' viability.
Why Technological Progress Is Now Reversing
The article discusses the disconnect between technological advancement and societal benefit, highlighting issues like user exploitation, lack of accountability, and the need for reevaluating technology's societal role.