August 27th, 2024

Sainsbury Wing contractors find 1990 letter from donor

During renovations at the Sainsbury Wing of London's National Gallery, a letter from donor John Sainsbury criticized non-structural columns. The £85 million upgrade includes their removal, reopening in May 2025.

Read original articleLink Icon
CuriosityAmusementNostalgia
Sainsbury Wing contractors find 1990 letter from donor

During renovation work at the Sainsbury Wing of London's National Gallery, contractors discovered a letter from John Sainsbury, a key donor, dated July 26, 1990. The letter, which was hidden in a false column, expressed Sainsbury's disapproval of the architect Robert Venturi's design choice to include two non-structural columns in the foyer. Sainsbury believed these columns were a significant mistake and anticipated that their presence would be regrettable. He expressed delight at the prospect of their removal, which was realized during the recent renovations aimed at upgrading the gallery. The Sainsbury Wing, funded by John and his brothers, opened in 1991 and is currently undergoing an £85 million upgrade to enhance visitor experience. The project includes the demolition of the criticized columns, which has faced some opposition from preservationists. The Sainsbury family remains the largest financial contributor to the renovation, with significant donations from family trusts. The refurbished Sainsbury Wing is expected to reopen in May 2025.

- A letter from John Sainsbury, found during renovations, criticized the inclusion of false columns in the Sainsbury Wing.

- The Sainsbury Wing is undergoing an £85 million upgrade, including the removal of the controversial columns.

- The Sainsbury family is the largest financial contributor to the renovation project.

- The refurbished wing is set to reopen in May 2025, allowing visitors to assess the architectural changes.

- The project has faced criticism from preservationists regarding the demolition of the columns.

AI: What people are saying
The comments on the article about the Sainsbury Wing renovations reflect a mix of humor, historical references, and cultural observations.
  • Several commenters draw parallels between the situation and historical architectural debates, such as Brunelleschi's work.
  • There is a recurring theme of British passive aggression, with many finding humor in the letter's tone.
  • Some comments highlight the serendipity of discovering the letter during renovations, suggesting a connection to past generations.
  • References to the architectural legacy and public opinion, including King Charles' past criticisms, are noted.
  • Commenters express amusement at the situation, with some calling it quintessentially British.
Link Icon 18 comments
By @dayjah - about 2 months
Reminds me of Filippo Brunelleschi; in the 1400s he grokked structural mechanics far better than anyone else and protested supporting the domed ceiling of the Pazzi chapel with columns. All the engineers of the time made the case he was wrong, and such a large dome needed support — he built the columns and had them finish a few inches short of the ceiling. This was discovered many years later and has become part of architecture lore.
By @JCM9 - about 2 months
This sort of thing is brilliant. Folks put things inside walls a lot.

When doing a bathroom repair I needed a few additional tiles that would be impossible to find (was an old house). Guess what I found when we busted open the wall… the leftover tiles from when the house was built like 70 years prior! I could almost feel some tile layer from generations prior giving me a little smile and pat on the back.

By @useless_foghorn - about 2 months
By @PhilRodgers - about 2 months
This reminds me of the letter in the pond https://thatcanadiangirl.co.uk/2008/05/30/the-letter-in-the-...
By @raldi - about 2 months
How do I set up Git to thank future generations for removing code I regret checking in?
By @worstspotgain - about 2 months
This is easily, without a doubt, the most British thing I've ever seen. Glorious.
By @lainga - about 2 months

    // TODO: evil hack!! refactor this
By @ggm - about 2 months
In case people miss the back story, this is "the carbuncle" which prince (now king) charles disliked immensely.

here's a recent story about the work to add this entry

https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2022/nov/06/nationa...

By @rsynnott - about 2 months
So, it seems like the architect died in 2018, and Sainsbury in 2022. This could all have been extremely awkward if they'd done the work a few years earlier...
By @thomasfl - about 2 months
The whole Architectural Uprising movement sort of started in 1984 when the young Prince Charles gave a speech at the Royal Institute of British Architects 150th anniversary gala evening. During his speech, the prince said that a proposed new modernist extension to the National Gallery was ugly. Or to be more precise, he called it a carbuncle in the face of a dear old friend.

The Venturi columns seems to lack entasis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entasis

By @fuzzfactor - about 2 months
Notice the supermarket company still had a Telex number in 1990.

Even though they had likely possessed a fax machine for quite some time already.

By @moomin - about 2 months
I note that if future generations had decided the columns were great and should stay the letter would never have been found.
By @0xbadcafebee - about 2 months
This might be the most British thing I've ever heard of
By @berniedurfee - about 2 months
This is brilliant!

I always leave stuff for future remodelers or archeologists when I do remodeling or building.

Mostly coins, I throw a few in the concrete mix or inside walls for future generations to discover.

It’s always a treat to find long forgotten artifacts when remodeling old houses.

A little treat for people working on something I built 40 or 400 years in the future.

By @nickdothutton - about 2 months
I think he was probably right, an adornment.
By @Taylor_OD - about 2 months
So funny. The perfect passive aggressive told you so ever.
By @klik99 - about 2 months
This might be the most passive aggressive thing I have ever heard. England truly elevates passive aggression to art form

EDIT: Someone downvoted me, so I should say I grew up in England until I was 14 so I'm allowed to say this! Downvoting itself is a form of passive aggression