August 28th, 2024

Telegram boss banned from leaving France in criminal probe

Pavel Durov, founder of Telegram, is under investigation in France for alleged organized crime activities, requiring a €5 million deposit and police reporting, amid concerns over social media accountability.

Read original articleLink Icon
Telegram boss banned from leaving France in criminal probe

Pavel Durov, the founder of Telegram, has been placed under formal investigation in France amid a criminal probe into organized crime activities associated with the messaging app. Paris prosecutors have indicated that Durov is under judicial supervision, requiring him to pay a €5 million deposit, report to a police station twice weekly, and remain in France. He was detained at Le Bourget airport under a warrant related to allegations including complicity in facilitating illicit transactions and the distribution of child sexual abuse images. While being under investigation does not imply guilt, it suggests sufficient grounds for further inquiry. Durov's lawyer asserts that Telegram adheres to European digital regulations and that the allegations are unfounded. The case has sparked discussions about freedom of speech and the accountability of social media platforms, with notable figures like Elon Musk defending Durov. Telegram, which has over 950 million users, has faced criticism for not participating in international efforts to combat child abuse material online. Durov, who previously left Russia due to government pressures, holds multiple nationalities and has been a controversial figure in the tech industry.

- Pavel Durov is under investigation in France for alleged organized crime activities linked to Telegram.

- He is required to pay a €5 million deposit and report to police twice a week.

- The allegations include complicity in illicit transactions and distribution of child sexual abuse images.

- The case raises concerns about freedom of speech and social media accountability.

- Telegram has been criticized for not joining international child protection initiatives.

Link Icon 10 comments
By @booleanbetrayal - 5 months
I'm fairly convinced that the arrest of Pavel Durov on content-moderation related issues is actually an attempt by a NATO state at securing information about adversaries, as it's the most used messaging app by Russian forces in Ukraine. Apparently the Wagner Group had developed their own messaging client, ostensibly for this reason.
By @sgjohnson - 5 months
IANAL, but I think that this case mostly has merit. Telegram is not end-to-end encrypted by default. So they have access to the conversations in group chats and non-E2E encrypted DMs.

One of the charges is refusal to provide information when requested by law enforcement. And he is a French citizen, so there might be an explicit obligation to cooperate with law enforcement when requested.

To me it sounds like he’s being done in for not putting E2E encryption on everything.

Whether he should be liable for what others do on his platform is a different matter entirely. But it has merit.

By @nashashmi - 5 months
Until he starts to capitulate to censorship, especially of anti-Israeli and pro-russian groups, they will continue to pin all indirect criminal activity on him.

Free speech is defined as speech free of threats to the establishment.

By @melbourne_mat - 5 months
He'll get out - maybe through the embassy. It's not like there would be extradition between Russia and France with the relationship as it is at the moment.
By @netsharc - 5 months
I wonder why Putin/Russia is yelling about this, the guy's become a persona non grata in Russia according to Wikipedia. Perhaps he's secretly cooperating with Putin? Or maybe Putin's regime is afraid the French will uncover their propaganda networks on Telegram...
By @wileydragonfly - 5 months
The first time I’d heard about Telegram being used was when some dude hacked those modern NeoGeo minis and was distributing CFW there. Figured it must be shady as hell. Have yet to see otherwise.
By @ex3ndr - 5 months
Boss? He is a founder, not a head of mafia.
By @SanjayMehta - 5 months
If Telegram is not end to end encrypted, then intelligence agencies already have the information they claim to be seeking.

Therefore the only purpose of this prosecution is to get Durov to toe the line.

The fact that this is happening just before the US elections is not a coincidence. Add to this the synchronised anti-Telegram propaganda from BBC, DW, French media.

He’s being told to play ball or else.