August 30th, 2024

'Green' Hydrogen Produces 37 Times More Global Warming Than Carbon Dioxide

Recent claims indicate 'green' hydrogen may cause more global warming than carbon dioxide, producing harmful pollutants and facing significant integration and production challenges, with no viable alternatives to hydrocarbons currently available.

Read original articleLink Icon
'Green' Hydrogen Produces 37 Times More Global Warming Than Carbon Dioxide

Recent claims suggest that 'green' hydrogen may produce 37 times more global warming than carbon dioxide over a 20-year period. This assertion is based on a study indicating that hydrogen, when oxidized, leads to the formation of greenhouse gases such as tropospheric ozone and stratospheric water vapor. The combustion of hydrogen also generates nitrogen dioxide, a pollutant linked to health issues like childhood asthma. Critics argue that hydrogen's properties make it an ineffective decarbonization tool, as it leaks more readily than natural gas and poses significant safety risks. The paper from the Environmental Defence Fund highlights the challenges of integrating hydrogen into existing natural gas systems, noting that blending hydrogen with natural gas yields only minor reductions in CO2 emissions. Furthermore, the manufacturing processes for hydrogen are fraught with challenges, and no production method is universally beneficial for the climate. The Royal Society has previously dismissed batteries as a viable solution for energy storage, leading to a reliance on hydrogen, which requires extensive infrastructure and poses environmental risks. Overall, the article argues that there is currently no cost-effective and reliable alternative to hydrocarbons, warning of potential energy shortages if current policies continue.

- 'Green' hydrogen may contribute significantly to global warming, more than previously thought.

- Hydrogen combustion produces harmful pollutants, including nitrogen dioxide.

- Integrating hydrogen into existing gas systems presents major safety and environmental challenges.

- Current hydrogen production methods face significant climate-related challenges.

- There is no viable alternative to hydrocarbons for energy needs in the near future.

Related

The greening of planes, trains and automobiles

The greening of planes, trains and automobiles

Decarbonization of transportation is vital for achieving net-zero emissions. The shift from fossil fuels to new, green fuels like batteries, hydrogen, biofuels, and synthetic hydrocarbons is crucial. Electric vehicles dominate light-duty traffic, while hydrogen fuel cells are emerging for heavy-duty vehicles. A mix of fuel types is expected by 2050 for net-zero emissions.

A hydrogen-powered air taxi flew 523 miles emitting only water vapor

A hydrogen-powered air taxi flew 523 miles emitting only water vapor

Joby Aviation's hydrogen-powered air taxi completes a 523-mile test emitting only water vapor, showcasing eco-friendly travel potential. Hydrogen power offers emission-free flight, aiming to reduce CO2 emissions in aviation.

Oil Companies Know Carbon Capture Is Not a Climate Solution

Oil Companies Know Carbon Capture Is Not a Climate Solution

Major oil companies are accused of misleading the public about carbon capture and storage (CCS) effectiveness. Investigations reveal skepticism within the industry, raising concerns about CCS's actual impact on climate change.

Converting captured carbon to fuel: Study assesses what's practical

Converting captured carbon to fuel: Study assesses what's practical

A University of Colorado Boulder study discusses the challenges of converting captured CO2 into fuel, highlighting the impracticality of reactive capture and proposing electrodialysis as a more efficient alternative.

Batteries Will Not Solve Renewable Energy Storage Problem (2023)

Batteries Will Not Solve Renewable Energy Storage Problem (2023)

The Royal Society's report reveals that current battery technology is inadequate for renewable energy storage, proposing hydrogen as an alternative despite significant logistical, safety, and cost challenges.

Link Icon 1 comments