August 30th, 2024

Batteries Will Not Solve Renewable Energy Storage Problem (2023)

The Royal Society's report reveals that current battery technology is inadequate for renewable energy storage, proposing hydrogen as an alternative despite significant logistical, safety, and cost challenges.

Read original articleLink Icon
Batteries Will Not Solve Renewable Energy Storage Problem (2023)

The Royal Society has released a report indicating that current battery technology is insufficient for the energy storage needs of renewable sources like wind and solar. Analyzing 37 years of wind patterns in Britain, the report suggests that the required storage capacity has been significantly underestimated. Led by Professor Sir Chris Llewellyn Smith, the study concludes that batteries cannot meet the vast energy storage demands, especially during periods of low renewable generation. Instead, the report proposes using hydrogen stored in large salt caverns, which presents its own challenges, including high costs, energy losses during transport, and the need for extensive infrastructure. Critics argue that hydrogen is not a practical solution due to its explosive nature, low density, and the substantial energy required for its movement. The report has been largely overlooked by mainstream media, and some experts express skepticism about the feasibility and cost-effectiveness of the proposed hydrogen infrastructure. The lead author emphasizes the urgency of developing long-term energy storage solutions to meet Net Zero targets, but concerns remain about the economic implications for consumers and the overall viability of the hydrogen approach.

- The Royal Society's report states that batteries cannot adequately store renewable energy.

- Hydrogen is proposed as an alternative, but it has significant logistical and safety challenges.

- Critics highlight the high costs and energy losses associated with hydrogen transport.

- The report has received little attention from mainstream media despite its critical findings.

- Urgent action is needed to develop energy storage solutions to meet Net Zero goals.

Related

Compressed Air Storage Redux – LightSail and Hydrostor

Compressed Air Storage Redux – LightSail and Hydrostor

Compressed air storage solutions like LightSail and Hydrostor are compared. Hydrostor's realistic approach gains attention for energy storage despite skepticism over water usage efficiency claims. Challenges persist in operational and construction aspects.

Batteries: How cheap can they get?

Batteries: How cheap can they get?

Batteries, especially sodium ones, may become significantly cheaper, revolutionizing the electricity grid, enhancing stability, and enabling wider renewable energy adoption. Predictions suggest prices could drop to $8/kWh by 2030, promoting grid stability and decentralized energy management.

The greening of planes, trains and automobiles

The greening of planes, trains and automobiles

Decarbonization of transportation is vital for achieving net-zero emissions. The shift from fossil fuels to new, green fuels like batteries, hydrogen, biofuels, and synthetic hydrocarbons is crucial. Electric vehicles dominate light-duty traffic, while hydrogen fuel cells are emerging for heavy-duty vehicles. A mix of fuel types is expected by 2050 for net-zero emissions.

Why did the U.S. miss the battery revolution?

Why did the U.S. miss the battery revolution?

The U.S. has lagged in battery technology, with China leading in manufacturing and innovation. Factors include supply chain issues and political opposition, resulting in missed opportunities for energy transition.

Why Wind Energy Is in a State of Crisis

Why Wind Energy Is in a State of Crisis

The wind energy sector faces challenges with declining capacity additions, financial losses, job cuts, increased local opposition, and supply chain disruptions. However, there are plans for new capacity in 2024.

Link Icon 1 comments