September 19th, 2024

US health system ranks last compared with peer nations, report finds – US news

A Commonwealth Fund report reveals the US health system ranks last among ten nations, highlighting issues in health equity and access, despite high spending. Major candidates lack substantial reform proposals.

Read original articleLink Icon
US health system ranks last compared with peer nations, report finds – US news

A recent Commonwealth Fund report has revealed that the United States health system ranks last among ten peer nations, despite Americans spending nearly double on healthcare compared to other countries. The report highlights significant shortcomings in health equity, access to care, and health outcomes. Dr. Joseph Betancourt, president of the Commonwealth Fund, emphasized the human toll of these deficiencies, noting that many patients struggle to afford medications and that older patients often arrive at hospitals in worse health due to lack of insurance. While healthcare costs are a primary concern for voters, neither major presidential candidate has proposed substantial reforms. The report, part of the "Mirror, Mirror" series, utilized 70 indicators across five sectors, showing the US consistently ranks at the bottom, except in care processes. Experts suggest that to improve the US health system, there needs to be an expansion of insurance coverage, simplification of insurance plans, enhancement of primary care, and investment in social wellbeing. However, implementing these changes is expected to be challenging, especially in the current political climate.

- The US health system ranks last among ten peer nations in a Commonwealth Fund report.

- Americans spend over $4.5 trillion annually on healthcare, yet face significant access and equity issues.

- Voter concerns about healthcare costs are not being addressed by major political candidates.

- Recommendations for improvement include expanding insurance coverage and simplifying insurance plans.

- The report indicates that social inequities significantly impact health outcomes in the US.

Related

America: A healthy or healthcare economy? The sickness at the heart of US GDP

America: A healthy or healthcare economy? The sickness at the heart of US GDP

The US economy heavily depends on healthcare, driving job growth and spending. Despite high healthcare expenditure, health outcomes lag behind. Inefficiencies like high costs and lack of universal coverage challenge resource allocation for better health.

UK healthcare is already being privatised, but not in the way you think

UK healthcare is already being privatised, but not in the way you think

Concerns about NHS privatization are rising in the UK, with a twenty-fold increase in crowdfunding for private healthcare due to long waiting times, impacting low-income households significantly.

U.S. Athletes Are Taking Full Advantage of Free Healthcare in Olympic Village

U.S. Athletes Are Taking Full Advantage of Free Healthcare in Olympic Village

U.S. athletes at the Paris 2024 Olympic Village are utilizing free healthcare services, highlighted by Ariana Ramsey's TikTok, contrasting with the U.S. lack of universal healthcare and financial struggles.

Americans dying younger than their English-speaking peers worldwide

Americans dying younger than their English-speaking peers worldwide

A study in BMJ Open shows Americans have the lowest life expectancy among high-income English-speaking countries, with preventable deaths and geographic disparities contributing to this issue, highlighting the need for public health reforms.

Ask HN: New to US, puzzled why tech hasn't simplified health insurance

Ask HN: New to US, puzzled why tech hasn't simplified health insurance

A software engineer from Europe finds the US health insurance system complex and outdated, expressing frustration over reliance on phone communication, lack of pricing transparency, and regulatory challenges, while seeking technological improvements.

Link Icon 17 comments
By @arjie - 27 days
One thing that's surprised me about the US is the general slowness of most things. In India, you can get MRIs and CT Scans same day. Or you could the last time I was there. And it didn't cost very much in comparison.

My doctors have all been good (attested to by my parents who are surgeons themselves) but the healthcare system is wonky.

One thing I didn't expect is that the Indian system where you just drag your health records around paper copy yourself is superior to US EMR systems - which doctors seem to always have trouble with.

But now I have some friends in medicine and I always have them pull my records and keep a copy myself. It's usually a fax but it's better that way. Clearly electronic interop isn't working most of the time.

By @ein0p - 27 days
Lately I can’t even get a doctor - both the specialist and primary care doctors are booked months in advance. And I have one of the best insurance coverages currently available. Remember how we laughed at Canadians and Brits waiting for months to see their free/cheap doctors? Well we’re at a point where we have to wait _and_ pay through the nose. And then they can’t really do anything or fuck you up even worse.
By @l5870uoo9y - 27 days
The UK performs better (third place) than, for example, Germany (second last place). The UK's healthcare system is often heavily criticized as being on the brink of collapse - any explanation for this?
By @kidsil - 27 days
I find it hard to trust a report that puts Canada above Germany in any healthcare related ranking. In terms of access, quality, and coverage, there's absolutely no comparison.
By @naming_the_user - 27 days
What does the ranking look like if you compare percentiles?

Naively I would assume as a non-American that if you're in the top 20% by income in the US you end up much better off than the top 20% income Brit, for example.

Or is it just actually worse for everyone? It feels intuitively obvious that the average will be worse because, well, the average person is skint and the US is less socialist.

By @alpineidyll3 - 27 days
The US likes to pretend free markets are our principle, but we have completely destroyed every notion of a free two-sided market on healthcare. That's the simple explanation for our outcome.
By @diogenescynic - 27 days
Quality of care is shit. Doctors barely care about their patients. It’s all a racket. Most areas seem to have a local monopoly that takes over the local hospitals. Obamacare has done nothing to really change anything meaningfully.
By @croes - 27 days
So Australia the #1 has the best outcome but is second to last in access to care?

Sounds like a lottery. If you win a place it's good otherwise not.

By @alexbadinici - 27 days
It's disheartening but not surprising to see the US health system ranking last among peer nations. Despite paying so much, we still struggle with access and equity. It's high time we prioritize real healthcare reform that addresses cost and outcomes, not just politics. https://templatecalendar.com/
By @jimbob45 - 27 days
It's unfair to judge the EU piecewise but then judge the US as a whole. Either let us compare apples to apples by judging the whole EU against the US or let us judge individual European member states against individual US states.
By @Madmallard - 27 days
So how do you get complex necessary medical care effectively in the United States?
By @davidguetta - 27 days
Yeah that's the funny part: in the US you should pay thousands of dollars for the basic exam / ambulance ride and many people don't have coverage while in entirety of europe is basically free, but the US gov is still paying 50% more in GDP than the other
By @fuckyah - 27 days
I'm sure it has nothing to do with the almost ~100 vaccine doses children are being subjected here...
By @cat_plus_plus - 27 days
Because we are paying for the rest of the world. Allow prescription drug imports from abroad. Pharma companies will be forced to charge more in the rest of the world and less in US. Allow insurance plans based on medical tourism for expensive procedures. Some countries will say no, but a lot of countries will say yes for profit. Once you have a choice of a hip replacement in Mexico or India, hospitals in these countries will compete for safety, cost, pleasant aftercare. Let's stop being the suckers.