October 1st, 2024

The Soldiers' Philosopher

Professor Nancy Sherman has worked with the military for over 20 years, focusing on ethics and Stoic philosophy. She addresses PTSD challenges and is releasing a book on soldiers' moral wounds.

Read original articleLink Icon
The Soldiers' Philosopher

Professor Nancy Sherman has spent over two decades working with the US military, focusing on military ethics and the philosophical underpinnings of soldiering. Her involvement began after a cheating scandal at the US Naval Academy, where she was invited to help establish an ethics course. Sherman found that military personnel, particularly officers, resonated with Stoic philosophy, which emphasizes control over one's emotions and acceptance of external circumstances. She highlights the dual nature of Stoicism for soldiers: it can provide resilience and coping mechanisms during tough times, but it may also lead to emotional detachment, making it difficult for veterans to reconnect with their feelings upon returning home. Sherman discusses the challenges soldiers face with PTSD, noting that the military is working to destigmatize it and improve mental health support. However, she points out that there is still a lack of mental health professionals and that many soldiers are heavily medicated, complicating their recovery. She also critiques programs like Martin Seligman's Comprehensive Soldier Fitness, suggesting that while they aim to prevent PTSD, they may inadvertently stigmatize those who still struggle. Sherman continues to engage with veterans in her classes and is set to release a book addressing the moral wounds of soldiers returning from war.

- Nancy Sherman has worked with the military for over 20 years, focusing on ethics and Stoic philosophy.

- Stoicism helps soldiers cope with challenges but can lead to emotional detachment.

- PTSD is a significant issue in the military, with efforts to destigmatize it ongoing.

- There is a shortage of mental health professionals available to support veterans.

- Sherman is releasing a book on healing the moral wounds of soldiers.

Related

Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Died by Suicide

Pattern of Brain Damage Is Pervasive in Navy SEALs Who Died by Suicide

A military lab identified brain damage patterns in Navy SEALs linked to blast exposure. SEAL leadership's lack of awareness hindered addressing the issue, impacting cognitive health. Research highlights widespread blast-induced brain injuries among active SEALs, urging improved communication and integration of brain injury research in military practices. Tragic cases emphasize the need for awareness and prevention measures.

Marcus Aurelius: On Humility and Duty (2019)

Marcus Aurelius: On Humility and Duty (2019)

Marcus Aurelius promotes humility and selfless actions for the common good, emphasizing duty over recognition, as illustrated by WWII veterans, highlighting the importance of community and cooperation in Stoic philosophy.

We've Got Depression All Wrong. It's Trying to Save Us

We've Got Depression All Wrong. It's Trying to Save Us

Recent research suggests depression may be a biological survival strategy linked to stress responses, challenging traditional views. Understanding it as such can reduce stigma and promote recovery through social connection.

The Magazine for Mercenaries Enters Polite Society

The Magazine for Mercenaries Enters Polite Society

Susan Katz Keating is modernizing Soldier of Fortune, focusing on its controversial history and predominantly male, right-leaning audience, while downplaying concerns about civil unrest and political violence.

Moral implications of being moderately successful computer scientist and a woman

Moral implications of being moderately successful computer scientist and a woman

Irene Y. Zhang discusses the moral implications of misogyny in computer science, highlighting harassment women face, moral fallacies undermining their roles, and urging men in power to become allies against these issues.

Link Icon 9 comments
By @KineticLensman - 7 months
I used to work with Soldiers a lot (I helped build training simulations) and was often amazed by their perspectives. I remember theoretical discussions (Q: when is the enemy defeated? A: when he thinks he is) alongside powerful raw emotions (Dutch peacekeepers unable to intervene in the Srebrenica massacre). On one project, where things were technically crashing around our ears, I was staggered by the emotional and practical support from soldiers who understood that I was on their side, more than I’ve ever experienced from civvie project managers. It's the closest I've come to crying with gratitude. That and the attitude: when you fall down, we will laugh, but we will help you up.

Respect.

By @quercusa - 7 months
(2014)

Interesting:

The Stoics were giving salvation for tough times. It’s a great philosophy for tough times, I’m not sure it’s a great philosophy for everyday living. It’s always good to feel more in control, but it’s not good to think that luck and the vicissitudes of the world can’t touch you or that you can’t show moral outrage, love, grief, and so on.

By @hackandthink - 7 months
We have 2.4 million soldiers coming home from war.

Hard to believe, but it is possible.

https://usafacts.org/articles/how-many-people-are-in-the-us-...

By @nonrandomstring - 7 months
Excellent read. Original perspectives too - just drop the D from PTSD and get with the idea that this is normal and the hardest people are soft on the inside.
By @paganel - 7 months
> What do you think of Martin Seligman’s Comprehensive Soldier Fitness programme [ a $180 million programme introduced in 2010 to teach resilient-thinking skills to all service-members, to try and prevent PTSD occurrence]?

Come on, this is a shill interview if I have ever saw one. Fuck all this, the US Army personnel, past and present, deserves way better than this psy-op-ed crap. All soldiers, former and present, deserve that.

And back to the, let's say essence, of the article, you could tell that it was written in 2014, back when Stoicism just had had a strong revival, hence why this lady is mentioning it ad-nauseam. I'd say that by 2016-2018 it was already gone, either way, large parts of the US/Western establishment sure as hell left Stoicism apart when confronted with Trump, for example.

By @bbor - 7 months

  You’re in a lethality and violence-soaked environment, increasingly in population-centric environments. There’s a lot of grey area - who’s the enemy, are they a voluntary or involuntary human-shield, and so on.
I guess she understandably doesn’t want to focus on that part, but this has to be a huge part of rising PTSD rates: it’s hard to ignore that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were ultimately immorally waged. What scientists call the “are we the baddies?-syndrome”