Writing Advice Is a Lie
Henry Oliver critiques oversimplified writing advice, emphasizing the importance of grammar and rhetoric. He advocates for mastering sentence structures and suggests reading widely to improve writing skills.
Read original article
Henry Oliver argues that much of the writing advice available today is misleading and ineffective. He criticizes the oversimplified guidance that encourages writers to "write like you speak" or to prioritize brevity over complexity. Instead, he emphasizes the importance of understanding grammar and rhetoric, asserting that grammar is fundamentally about logic. Oliver contends that good writing requires a mastery of various sentence structures and techniques, rather than adherence to generic advice. He points out that many popular writing tips misinterpret literary examples, failing to recognize the artistic purpose behind them. For instance, he critiques the misuse of Charles Dickens' famous opening line from "A Tale of Two Cities," arguing that it is not merely about simplicity but about conveying complexity with intention. Oliver advocates for a deeper engagement with the rules of writing, suggesting that aspiring writers should focus on studying grammar and rhetoric through reputable guides and reading exemplary literature. He concludes that the best writing advice is actually to read widely and learn from established works, rather than relying on superficial tips.
- Much writing advice is oversimplified and misleading.
- Understanding grammar and rhetoric is crucial for effective writing.
- Good writing requires mastery of various sentence structures and techniques.
- Misinterpretation of literary examples can lead to poor writing practices.
- The best writing advice is to read widely and learn from established authors.
Related
How to think in writing
Henrik Karlsson emphasizes writing's role in refining thinking by making ideas precise and complete. Writing helps transition from fluid thoughts to clear claims, inviting feedback for deeper understanding and improvement.
How to Think in Writing
Henrik Karlsson emphasizes writing as a tool to refine thinking by making ideas precise and complete. Drawing from personal experiences and Imre Lakatos's work, he advocates for clear claims and thorough explanations to enhance understanding.
Learning by Writing
The article discusses a learning method centered on writing, emphasizing forming bold hypotheses, defending them, seeking counterarguments, and revising opinions. This approach fosters deep understanding and nuanced views through continuous exploration.
Writing Technical Documents Well
Effective technical writing requires clarity, simplicity, and audience awareness. Key strategies include structured storytelling, active voice, and avoiding jargon, ensuring documents remain relevant and impactful over time.
Technical writing is too important to leave to language models
The article argues that technical writing cannot be replaced by language models, emphasizing the need for personal experience, contextual understanding, and the ongoing demand for skilled writers in the tech industry.
0 commentsRelated
How to think in writing
Henrik Karlsson emphasizes writing's role in refining thinking by making ideas precise and complete. Writing helps transition from fluid thoughts to clear claims, inviting feedback for deeper understanding and improvement.
How to Think in Writing
Henrik Karlsson emphasizes writing as a tool to refine thinking by making ideas precise and complete. Drawing from personal experiences and Imre Lakatos's work, he advocates for clear claims and thorough explanations to enhance understanding.
Learning by Writing
The article discusses a learning method centered on writing, emphasizing forming bold hypotheses, defending them, seeking counterarguments, and revising opinions. This approach fosters deep understanding and nuanced views through continuous exploration.
Writing Technical Documents Well
Effective technical writing requires clarity, simplicity, and audience awareness. Key strategies include structured storytelling, active voice, and avoiding jargon, ensuring documents remain relevant and impactful over time.
Technical writing is too important to leave to language models
The article argues that technical writing cannot be replaced by language models, emphasizing the need for personal experience, contextual understanding, and the ongoing demand for skilled writers in the tech industry.