The US is the world’s science superpower — but for how long?
The US leads in science but faces competition from China. The upcoming election will influence funding and policies, impacting international talent retention and future scientific leadership amid budget constraints.
Read original article
The United States currently holds a dominant position in global science, having won more Nobel prizes than any other nation and investing significantly in research and development (R&D). However, concerns are rising about its future leadership in science, particularly in light of increasing competition from China, which is rapidly advancing in key scientific metrics. The upcoming presidential election is seen as crucial for determining the future of US science, as it will influence funding, immigration policies, and international collaboration. Despite the US spending approximately $1 trillion on R&D, China's investment is also surging, and it has already surpassed the US in producing scientific articles and PhDs. The US's reliance on international talent is another area of concern, as it attracts a significant number of foreign researchers, particularly from China and India. However, the perception of the US as less welcoming to foreigners could jeopardize its ability to retain this talent. The future of US science will depend on the next administration's commitment to funding and policies that support scientific research and education, especially in the face of a divided Congress and potential budget constraints.
- The US currently leads in scientific achievements but faces increasing competition from China.
- The upcoming election will significantly impact the direction of US science funding and policies.
- The US relies heavily on international talent, with a notable percentage of STEM PhDs awarded to foreign students.
- Concerns exist about the US's declining share of international students and researchers.
- Future scientific leadership will depend on sustained federal investment and a welcoming environment for foreign talent.
Related
Federal funding for major science agencies is at a 25 year low
Federal funding for major science agencies in the U.S. hits a 25-year low, affecting agencies like the National Science Foundation and NASA. Budget constraints hinder scientific workforce training and innovation amidst rising global competition.
China–US research collaborations are in decline – this is bad news for everyone
China's scientific collaborations, notably with the US, have decreased due to political tensions and pandemic effects. Experts stress the need to revive partnerships to tackle global challenges effectively.
America is sabotaging itself in the global battle for talent
America faces challenges in attracting skilled talent, with Donald Trump advocating for automatic green cards for graduates. Current policies may deter foreign professionals, risking a talent drain and competitiveness.
China Is Rapidly Becoming a Leading Innovator in Advanced Industries
China is advancing rapidly in advanced industries, particularly electric vehicles and nuclear power, challenging Western firms. U.S. strategies must adapt to maintain technological competitiveness amid China's growing innovation capabilities.
the US led nuclear fusion for decades. Now China is in position to win the race
The U.S. and China are intensifying competition in nuclear fusion energy, with China investing more annually and achieving rapid advancements, raising concerns about the U.S. losing its historical leadership.
6 comments1) Go back to the early policies enacted for driving Science & Technology using Public Funding specifically for Specialized Institutes and the overall Education System.
2) Pour more money into the above as much as possible so as to attract top talent into it.
3) Invite Immigration from all over the World with a clear path from Higher Education to Citizenship.
4) Continue to allow the Private Sector to do what it is already doing to great success.
And Oh; keep the petty Politics out of it. The US' advantage over China is 3 & 4.
For me, the key is the data. I've never seen so much information, presented so clearly. The trends are quite clear. As someone who works in research, none of what I saw was actually surprising, but the article is a very helpful integrative resource.
The irony of this closing sentence being about 5 paragraphs below a paragraph praising Harris and bashing Trump was noticed by, apparently, nobody at Nature.
To be clear, I’m not a fan of Trump and I’ve never voted for him, but surely Nature should just stay out of explicit endorsements and bashing of one or the other political side if they are at all concerned about science becoming an ‘ideological endeavour’. It’s borderline insane to me that they would engage in blatant partisanship right after extolling the value of science at least APPEARING to be politically neutral.
Related
Federal funding for major science agencies is at a 25 year low
Federal funding for major science agencies in the U.S. hits a 25-year low, affecting agencies like the National Science Foundation and NASA. Budget constraints hinder scientific workforce training and innovation amidst rising global competition.
China–US research collaborations are in decline – this is bad news for everyone
China's scientific collaborations, notably with the US, have decreased due to political tensions and pandemic effects. Experts stress the need to revive partnerships to tackle global challenges effectively.
America is sabotaging itself in the global battle for talent
America faces challenges in attracting skilled talent, with Donald Trump advocating for automatic green cards for graduates. Current policies may deter foreign professionals, risking a talent drain and competitiveness.
China Is Rapidly Becoming a Leading Innovator in Advanced Industries
China is advancing rapidly in advanced industries, particularly electric vehicles and nuclear power, challenging Western firms. U.S. strategies must adapt to maintain technological competitiveness amid China's growing innovation capabilities.
the US led nuclear fusion for decades. Now China is in position to win the race
The U.S. and China are intensifying competition in nuclear fusion energy, with China investing more annually and achieving rapid advancements, raising concerns about the U.S. losing its historical leadership.