Wikipedia Offers to Reveal User Identities in Sealed Covers in ANI Case
Wikipedia will provide user data to the Delhi High Court regarding edits to the ANI page, maintaining confidentiality. The case addresses defamation claims and the responsibilities of online intermediaries.
Read original articleWikipedia has agreed to provide basic subscriber information about users who edited the Asian News International (ANI) page to the Delhi High Court in a sealed cover. This decision was made during an appeal hearing on October 28, where Wikipedia's Senior Advocate Akhil Sibal stated that the identities of the users would remain confidential while the court would receive the necessary information. The case stems from ANI's defamation lawsuit against Wikipedia, claiming that the Wikipedia page misrepresented the agency as a government propaganda tool. ANI is seeking the removal of the content and monetary damages, arguing that Wikipedia, as a widely viewed intermediary, should not act as a private entity. The court had previously ordered Wikipedia to take down a page related to the defamation case, labeling it an interference in court proceedings. The ongoing legal battle highlights the tensions between user anonymity on platforms like Wikipedia and the demands for accountability in cases of alleged misinformation.
- Wikipedia will share user data with the court while keeping identities confidential.
- ANI alleges defamation due to misrepresentation on Wikipedia's page.
- The case raises questions about the responsibilities of intermediaries like Wikipedia.
- The Delhi High Court has previously ordered the removal of related content from Wikipedia.
- The legal proceedings reflect ongoing debates about misinformation and user privacy.
Related
Wikipedia summoned by Delhi High Court over ANI defamation allegations
The Delhi High Court summons Wikipedia over a defamation suit by ANI, alleging defamatory edits on its page. Court acknowledges concerns, schedules next hearing for August 20 to examine claims. ANI disputes statements on Wikipedia.
Iranian Regime Impacts Persian Wikipedia by Manipulation, Censorship
The Iranian regime manipulates Persian Wikipedia to distort information and conceal actions, using hired contributors for propaganda. User confidentiality and freedom of expression are at risk amid ongoing control efforts.
In a first, Wikipedia takes down article globally after Delhi HC order
Wikipedia removed an article following a Delhi High Court order, marking a global first. The court ruled it interfered with ongoing proceedings in a defamation case against Wikimedia by ANI.
Wikipedia article blocked worldwide by Delhi high court
The Wikimedia Foundation suspended access to a page due to a Delhi High Court directive, while exploring legal options and reaffirming its commitment to knowledge as a fundamental human right.
Wikipedia agrees to share details with Delhi Court about users who made edits
Wikipedia will provide the Delhi High Court with user information related to edits on ANI's page, maintaining confidentiality. The defamation case against Wikipedia by ANI remains pending, with ongoing court concerns.
The core issue here is that ANI - an indian news syndication agency - has regular and credible accusations of being biased towards india's hindu nationalist government. ANI sued Wikipedia in court using the argument of defamation.
There is a serious threat to freedom of speech in india and the indian state is only too happy to indirectly threaten media houses via the tax authorities.
See also the Indian Broadcast bill, where the state tries to "regulate" speech on platforms like youtube. In typical incompetent fashion, this is textbook overreach that is simultaneously vague but broad reaching.
https://www.newslaundry.com/2024/08/02/broadcast-bill-explai...
Related
Wikipedia summoned by Delhi High Court over ANI defamation allegations
The Delhi High Court summons Wikipedia over a defamation suit by ANI, alleging defamatory edits on its page. Court acknowledges concerns, schedules next hearing for August 20 to examine claims. ANI disputes statements on Wikipedia.
Iranian Regime Impacts Persian Wikipedia by Manipulation, Censorship
The Iranian regime manipulates Persian Wikipedia to distort information and conceal actions, using hired contributors for propaganda. User confidentiality and freedom of expression are at risk amid ongoing control efforts.
In a first, Wikipedia takes down article globally after Delhi HC order
Wikipedia removed an article following a Delhi High Court order, marking a global first. The court ruled it interfered with ongoing proceedings in a defamation case against Wikimedia by ANI.
Wikipedia article blocked worldwide by Delhi high court
The Wikimedia Foundation suspended access to a page due to a Delhi High Court directive, while exploring legal options and reaffirming its commitment to knowledge as a fundamental human right.
Wikipedia agrees to share details with Delhi Court about users who made edits
Wikipedia will provide the Delhi High Court with user information related to edits on ANI's page, maintaining confidentiality. The defamation case against Wikipedia by ANI remains pending, with ongoing court concerns.