November 7th, 2024

The Deterioration of Google

Independent publishers are experiencing significant traffic declines due to changes in Google's search algorithms, leading to site shutdowns and financial struggles, while Google's indifference raises concerns about content diversity online.

Read original articleLink Icon
The Deterioration of Google

The article discusses the decline of Google’s effectiveness as a search engine, particularly for independent publishers. Many independent media sites, including Giant Freakin Robot, have shut down due to a significant drop in traffic, largely attributed to changes in Google's search algorithms driven by machine learning. Publishers report that their content, which was previously successful, is now largely invisible in search results, leading to dire financial consequences. Despite efforts to communicate these issues to Google, the response has been dismissive, indicating a lack of concern for the struggles of smaller publishers. The article highlights that Google's algorithm has become increasingly opaque, with even its engineers unable to understand why certain content is being deprioritized. This situation is exacerbated by the monopolistic nature of Google, which continues to thrive regardless of the declining utility of its services. The author suggests that the tech industry's monopolies are likely to strengthen, further diminishing the prospects for independent publishers and the overall quality of search results.

- Independent publishers are facing severe declines in traffic due to changes in Google's search algorithms.

- Many sites have shut down, and those remaining are struggling to survive.

- Google's machine learning algorithms are failing to recognize valuable content, leading to a lack of visibility for smaller publishers.

- The situation reflects a broader issue of monopolistic practices in the tech industry, which may worsen over time.

- Google's indifference to the plight of independent publishers raises concerns about the future of diverse content online.

Link Icon 10 comments
By @aorth - 6 months
On one of my sites I received a million requests from Googlebot before lunchtime today. Those requests were spread over hundreds of IPs. I get similar traffic from them and other hyper scalers daily. I'm just one guy. I don't have load balancers and endless engineering budget. I'm sick of this.
By @ggm - 6 months
Surely if you're dependent on search, you don't HAVE organic business no matter that they call it organic search traffic? "that thing I get from whosit but I don't recall them yea them" is kind of always going to be very variable.

That said a colleague said when his brother-in-law stopped paying for placement his printer/toner supply business tanked, despite him believing they knew who he was. Nobody knows anyone.

By @DeathArrow - 6 months
Maybe Google doesn't want people to reach businesses from search results and they want businesses to pay for ads so people can reach them.
By @iamthepieman - 6 months
If you can afford it, please try kagi[0]. It's not a panacea. It IS a lot better than Google and has been for some time.

[0] https://kagi.com/welcome

By @RoderickBeck - 6 months
Machine learning is by definition a black box. Nonlinear statistical models with huge numbers of parameters to be estimated.
By @DeathArrow - 6 months
Everyone is complaining about Google since years ago. But no one has built a good alternative. Is it a bad business idea?
By @josefritzishere - 6 months
At some point, their business model being replicable, they plant the seeds for their own future compeition.
By @johnea - 6 months
Goggle stock is rising, executive pay is some of the highest in the world.

What is the "deterioration" of which you speak?

Search results, either reading them, or getting listed in them, is a user experience.

Why should goggle, or any for-profit company, care at all about user experience outside of the compainy's profit margins and growth?

Once again, let's refer to Dr. Frankenfurter's famous quote:

"I didn't make it for you!"