Human Interaction Is Now a Luxury Good
The article highlights how technology complicates emotional support roles in nursing, chaplaincy, and teaching, leading to unequal care access and declining trust in institutions, while emphasizing the need for genuine human connection.
Read original articleThe article discusses the increasing reliance on technology in professions that require human interaction, such as nursing, chaplaincy, and teaching. Sociologist Allison Pugh's book, "The Last Human Job," highlights the challenges faced by workers in these fields, who often find themselves burdened by technology that complicates their ability to provide emotional support. For instance, Erin Nash, a hospital chaplain, struggles with inefficient online systems that detract from her ability to connect with grieving families. Pugh argues that the push for productivity through technology undermines the essence of "connective labor," which cannot be easily quantified or standardized. The article also points out a growing divide in access to quality human care, where wealthier individuals receive personalized attention while others face impersonal, rushed services. This shift contributes to a decline in trust in institutions, as people feel increasingly disconnected from those who serve them. Pugh suggests that while technology has advanced, the human desire for genuine interaction remains strong, and a future dominated by machine interactions is not inevitable. The article concludes by emphasizing the importance of valuing care work to maintain meaningful human connections.
- Technology is complicating emotional support roles in healthcare and education.
- Wealth disparities are leading to unequal access to quality human care.
- The decline in human interaction contributes to a loss of trust in institutions.
- Genuine human connection remains essential despite technological advancements.
- The future of care work can still prioritize human interaction over machine reliance.
Related
The Triumph of Counting and Scripting
The article explores how data analytics and standardization are reshaping connective labor jobs in the US, impacting professions like teaching and therapy. It warns of threats to creativity and human connections, advocating for safeguarding feeling jobs.
People, Not Robots: Bringing the Humanity Back to Customer Support
The article emphasizes the importance of human interaction in customer support, arguing that companies should prioritize well-trained, respected teams to enhance customer satisfaction and loyalty over automation.
> We’re increasingly becoming a society where very wealthy people get obsequious, leisurely human care, like concierge medicine paid out of pocket, private schools with tiny class sizes and dead tree books, and apothecaries with personal shoppers. And everybody else might receive long wait times for 15-minute appointments with harried doctors, a public school system with overworked teachers who are supplemented by unproven apps to “personalize” learning and a pharmacy with self-checkout.
My take: The blind pursuit of KPIs that seek to measure "the achievement of goals" has led to so much automation that in many settings people can now interact only with or through machines.
Related
The Triumph of Counting and Scripting
The article explores how data analytics and standardization are reshaping connective labor jobs in the US, impacting professions like teaching and therapy. It warns of threats to creativity and human connections, advocating for safeguarding feeling jobs.
People, Not Robots: Bringing the Humanity Back to Customer Support
The article emphasizes the importance of human interaction in customer support, arguing that companies should prioritize well-trained, respected teams to enhance customer satisfaction and loyalty over automation.