January 11th, 2025

The Supreme Court doesn't seem likely to save TikTok

The Supreme Court is reviewing TikTok v. Garland, which may result in a U.S. ban on TikTok due to national security concerns, with a decision expected before January 19.

Read original articleLink Icon
The Supreme Court doesn't seem likely to save TikTok

The Supreme Court recently heard arguments in the case TikTok v. Garland, which could lead to a ban on the popular social media app in the United States due to its ownership by the Chinese company ByteDance. The law in question, set to take effect on January 19, effectively prohibits TikTok's operation unless it is sold to a non-foreign entity. During the hearing, the justices expressed skepticism towards TikTok's legal arguments, particularly regarding First Amendment rights. The government contends that the ban is a national security measure aimed at preventing data collection by a foreign adversary, rather than a restriction on free speech. Several justices raised concerns about the implications of the ban on free speech rights, while also acknowledging the government's historical precedent of restricting foreign ownership of U.S. communications infrastructure. The justices appeared divided on how to balance these competing legal principles, but the overall sentiment leaned towards upholding the ban. The Court's decision is expected to be issued before the law takes effect, and indications suggest that TikTok may not prevail in this case.

- The Supreme Court is considering a case that could lead to a ban on TikTok in the U.S.

- The law banning TikTok is based on national security concerns regarding foreign ownership.

- Justices expressed skepticism about TikTok's First Amendment arguments during the hearing.

- The Court's decision is anticipated before the law's effective date of January 19.

- The outcome may significantly impact the future of TikTok and its users in the U.S.

Link Icon 1 comments
By @blowsand - 3 months
I haven’t listened to many Supreme Court hearings. Historically has their line of questioning been a good indicator of how they ultimately ruled?