Vibe Coding Is Not My Future
Maximilian Schwarzmüller critiques "Vibe Coding," a method using large language models for coding, highlighting inefficiencies, potential bugs, and chaos in team settings, advocating for traditional coding skills and understanding.
Read original articleMaximilian Schwarzmüller discusses the emerging concept of "Vibe Coding," a method of programming that relies heavily on large language models (LLMs) to generate code based on simple prompts. This approach, popularized by Andrej Karpathy, allows users to create applications by merely requesting features or bug fixes without deep engagement with the code itself. While some individuals have found success with vibe coding, Schwarzmüller shares his negative experience, highlighting the inefficiencies and potential pitfalls of this method. He argues that knowing how to code is generally more productive than relying on LLMs, as it allows for a better understanding of the code and its potential issues. He also points out that treating code as a "black box" can lead to undetected bugs and security vulnerabilities. Furthermore, he expresses concerns about the chaotic nature of vibe coding in team environments, where clear plans and collaboration are essential. Schwarzmüller concludes that while vibe coding may assist those with limited coding skills, it is not a sustainable future for serious developers, who should prioritize skill development and understanding over reliance on AI-generated solutions.
- Vibe Coding relies on LLMs to generate code from simple prompts, but may lead to inefficiencies.
- Understanding code is crucial for identifying bugs and security issues, which vibe coding may overlook.
- Vibe coding can create chaos in team projects due to its lack of structure and planning.
- Relying solely on AI for coding can hinder skill development and understanding of programming concepts.
- The unpredictability of LLM outputs raises concerns about the reliability of using natural language for coding.
Related
Vibe Coding and the Future of Software Engineering
Vibe coding, popularized by Andrej Karpathy, raises concerns about code quality and junior developers' skills. While some embrace it, established organizations prefer traditional practices amid increasing AI integration in software development.
What is vibe coding? How creators are building software with no coding knowledge
Vibe coding is an AI-assisted software development method enabling non-technical creators to build applications by describing ideas in plain language, significantly reducing development time and skill requirements.
Vibe Coding
Vibe coding, introduced by Andrej Karpathy, enables non-programmers to create software with AI assistance, using tools like Replit Agent. Reception is mixed, highlighting accessibility but noting functional limitations.
Here's how I use LLMs to help me write code
Simon Willison shares insights on using Large Language Models in coding, emphasizing realistic expectations, clear instructions, and iterative testing. He promotes "vibe-coding" for creativity while advocating human oversight.
Vibe coding is not coding
Vibe coding, introduced by Andrej Karpathy, enables AI to generate code from high-level queries, enhancing efficiency and allowing developers to focus on abstract reasoning in large codebases.
Related
Vibe Coding and the Future of Software Engineering
Vibe coding, popularized by Andrej Karpathy, raises concerns about code quality and junior developers' skills. While some embrace it, established organizations prefer traditional practices amid increasing AI integration in software development.
What is vibe coding? How creators are building software with no coding knowledge
Vibe coding is an AI-assisted software development method enabling non-technical creators to build applications by describing ideas in plain language, significantly reducing development time and skill requirements.
Vibe Coding
Vibe coding, introduced by Andrej Karpathy, enables non-programmers to create software with AI assistance, using tools like Replit Agent. Reception is mixed, highlighting accessibility but noting functional limitations.
Here's how I use LLMs to help me write code
Simon Willison shares insights on using Large Language Models in coding, emphasizing realistic expectations, clear instructions, and iterative testing. He promotes "vibe-coding" for creativity while advocating human oversight.
Vibe coding is not coding
Vibe coding, introduced by Andrej Karpathy, enables AI to generate code from high-level queries, enhancing efficiency and allowing developers to focus on abstract reasoning in large codebases.