March 18th, 2025

Columbia University Revokes Degrees of Pro-Palestinian Student Protesters

Columbia University expelled or suspended students and revoked diplomas for protesting Israel's actions in Gaza, influenced by federal funding cuts, raising debates on free speech and civil disobedience.

Read original articleLink Icon
Columbia University Revokes Degrees of Pro-Palestinian Student Protesters

Columbia University has expelled or suspended several students involved in a protest against Israel's actions in Gaza, and has temporarily revoked the diplomas of some graduates who participated in the demonstration. This decision follows a campus-wide email announcement and comes amid heightened tensions after the arrest of Mahmoud Khalil, a pro-Palestinian activist. The university's actions were influenced by the Trump administration's withdrawal of over $400 million in federal funding, citing a failure to address antisemitism on campus. President Trump had previously threatened to penalize universities that allowed protests he deemed illegal. In response to the situation, Columbia University expressed its commitment to combating antisemitism and ensuring the safety of its community while also seeking to restore its federal funding. The university's stance has sparked discussions about free speech and civil disobedience, with advocates arguing that peaceful protests should be protected.

- Columbia University has expelled or suspended students for protesting against Israel.

- The university temporarily revoked diplomas of some graduates involved in the protests.

- The actions were influenced by federal funding cuts from the Trump administration.

- Columbia is committed to addressing antisemitism and ensuring campus safety.

- The situation has raised debates about free speech and civil disobedience in academic settings.

Link Icon 5 comments
By @alwa - 26 days
What does it mean to "temporarily revoke" a diploma? It seems like you either earned it or you didn't. Measures like expulsion and suspension might interrupt ongoing bad behavior with the consequence that people can't then finish earning their diplomas—but once they're earned, how does it make sense that they're retrospectively un-earned?

It feels like such a mobster mentality—the diploma doesn't mean anything with respect to objective achievements, it's just a mark of someone powerful's favor, and you'd better stay in their favor...

By @gnabgib - 26 days
Small discussion (25 points, 7 days ago, 17 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43316590
By @bhouston - 26 days
Free speech in the USA seems to have a Palestine exception.

The number of logical fallacies in this set of events is pretty strange. First they conflate anti-semitism with protesting what many credible people have called a genocide. Then the US government is stripping $400M in funding to pressure the university to do these things. Lastly, these students are not charged with crimes, so they are punishing them for non-criminal actions.

Weird times.

By @jmclnx - 26 days
Well I guess what is more important to these places, money from the federal gov. Free and Open exchange of Ideas, not in US Univ. and Colleges these days.