US Courts to Decide If NFTs Are Securities as DraftKings Case Goes to Trial
US courts are evaluating if NFTs should be deemed securities in a case involving DraftKings. The lawsuit alleges DraftKings' sports-themed NFTs meet securities criteria, impacting the NFT market and industry diversification.
Read original article
US courts are set to determine whether NFTs should be classified as securities in a trial involving DraftKings. The case, Dufoe v. DraftKings Inc., alleges that DraftKings' sports-themed NFTs on the Polygon blockchain meet the criteria of the Howey test, potentially categorizing them as securities. The judge denied DraftKings' motion to dismiss the lawsuit, signaling a significant legal battle that could impact the NFT landscape. This development comes at a crucial time for the NFT market, which has experienced a decline in sales volumes in Q2 2024. Despite this, the NFT ecosystem continues to expand into various industries beyond digital art, with applications in sports collectibles, virtual real estate, and digital fashion. The outcome of this trial could have broad implications for how NFTs are regulated and marketed, potentially affecting companies' strategies and financial performance in the future.
Related
Supreme Court rules that the SEC's in-house rulings violate US constitution
The US Supreme Court ruled SEC's in-house proceedings violate jury trial rights, impacting fraud fighting. Decision criticized, SEC loses tool. Trend limits regulators' power, sparks debate on agency-judiciary balance.
Supreme Court limits use of SEC in-house tribunals
The Supreme Court ruled against SEC's use of internal tribunals in fraud cases, citing constitutional violations. Experts predict fewer enforcement actions due to required jury trials, impacting federal agencies' power and regulatory authority.
NFL is liable for $4,707,259,944 in 'Sunday Ticket' case
A federal jury orders NFL to pay $4.7 billion for antitrust violations related to "Sunday Ticket" service. NFL found liable for inflating prices and limiting competition. Appeals pending, potential changes to service.
Apple first rejected, then quickly approved, Epic's app store in Europe
Epic Games challenges Apple's rejection of its European game store launch, involving the European Commission. The dispute, part of a broader regulatory feud, centers on Apple's 30% in-app purchase cut. EU regulators investigate Apple, Google, and Meta for DMA non-compliance.
U.S. SEC Wins 'Shadow Insider Trading' Trial
The SEC won a trial on "shadow insider trading" involving Matthew Panuwat trading call options in Incyte using confidential information about Medivation. The verdict sets a precedent for market participants.
4 commentsasset types themselves are not securities and neither a judge or the regulator is trying to decide that. transactions involving those assets can be securities and are tightly regulated.
some assets are standardized and only issued in a specific set of transactions 100% of the time, such that its redundant to call them anything other than securities. for assets that aren't standardized, the sequence of transactions has to be analyzed to determine if that set of transactions constituted a securities transaction.
this can be corroborated by how the courts have been reaching the conclusion that crypto asset's primary market (the initial sell or distribution from the creator to purchasers) has to be treated different from the secondary market trading (where the prices are listed on exchanges and fluctuate all day, everyday, which attracts most headlines and mindshare).
clarity from Congress about what level of consumer and investor protection is desired is what's really lacking here. The "securities" framework doesn't do that.
Related
Supreme Court rules that the SEC's in-house rulings violate US constitution
The US Supreme Court ruled SEC's in-house proceedings violate jury trial rights, impacting fraud fighting. Decision criticized, SEC loses tool. Trend limits regulators' power, sparks debate on agency-judiciary balance.
Supreme Court limits use of SEC in-house tribunals
The Supreme Court ruled against SEC's use of internal tribunals in fraud cases, citing constitutional violations. Experts predict fewer enforcement actions due to required jury trials, impacting federal agencies' power and regulatory authority.
NFL is liable for $4,707,259,944 in 'Sunday Ticket' case
A federal jury orders NFL to pay $4.7 billion for antitrust violations related to "Sunday Ticket" service. NFL found liable for inflating prices and limiting competition. Appeals pending, potential changes to service.
Apple first rejected, then quickly approved, Epic's app store in Europe
Epic Games challenges Apple's rejection of its European game store launch, involving the European Commission. The dispute, part of a broader regulatory feud, centers on Apple's 30% in-app purchase cut. EU regulators investigate Apple, Google, and Meta for DMA non-compliance.
U.S. SEC Wins 'Shadow Insider Trading' Trial
The SEC won a trial on "shadow insider trading" involving Matthew Panuwat trading call options in Incyte using confidential information about Medivation. The verdict sets a precedent for market participants.