August 8th, 2024

China's Real Economic Crisis

China's economy faces challenges with low GDP growth, declining consumer confidence, and overcapacity due to prioritizing production over consumption, complicating international trade and necessitating careful consideration by Western policymakers.

Read original articleLink Icon
China's Real Economic Crisis

China's economy is facing significant challenges following the abrupt end of its "zero COVID" policy in late 2022. Contrary to expectations of a swift recovery, the economy has struggled with sluggish GDP growth, declining consumer confidence, and a severe real estate crisis leading to defaults among major companies. Official data from July 2024 indicated that GDP growth was falling short of the government's target of around five percent. Analysts attribute this stagnation to several factors, including an aging population, Xi Jinping's tightening grip on the economy, and a long-standing industrial strategy that prioritizes production over consumption. This approach has resulted in structural overcapacity, where production exceeds both domestic and foreign demand, leading to price declines, insolvencies, and factory closures. The situation has also destabilized international trade, with Chinese firms flooding global markets with cheap goods, prompting concerns from Western leaders about unfair trade practices. Despite the need for a shift towards a more balanced economic model that includes increased consumption, the Chinese government remains unlikely to change its course due to its reliance on industrial output for political stability. The overcapacity issue poses long-term challenges for both China and the global economy, necessitating a nuanced understanding from Western policymakers to avoid exacerbating the situation.

- China's economy is struggling with low GDP growth and declining consumer confidence.

- The overcapacity issue stems from decades of prioritizing industrial production over consumption.

- China's industrial policies have led to significant trade imbalances and global market disruptions.

- The government is unlikely to shift its economic strategy due to its reliance on industrial output for political stability.

- Western policymakers need to understand these dynamics to avoid worsening the situation.

Link Icon 1 comments
By @toomuchtodo - 5 months
I think what’s important to remember is that China always had more domestic production capacity than what was going to be possible to sink into domestic consumption. This was hidden by their real estate boom, which has now ended. Now, the world is the sink for the productivity of China’s working age population (which will shrink as China rapidly ages).

If China wants to be a Tech and Clean Energy/Mobility powerhouse, and climate change is an emergency, this is not a bad thing. Surely this is a more worthy cause for human labor and time than building units that may never have a resident.

China prioritizes real value, its manufacturing base, engineering, science. Their ability to build is a muscle they maintain and flex. If counterparties value line goes up in a magic database instead (Boeing and Intel come to mind), that is going to lead to a bad time.