August 11th, 2024

Custom ROMs have had just about enough of being Android's second-class citizens

Tensions are rising between custom ROM developers, particularly Graphene OS, and Google over Play Integrity API compliance, with potential legal action looming if support for custom ROMs is not extended.

Read original articleLink Icon
Custom ROMs have had just about enough of being Android's second-class citizens

Tensions are escalating between custom ROM developers, particularly Graphene OS, and Google over the Play Integrity API, which is essential for app verification on Android devices. Custom ROMs, often used for enhanced features or privacy, face significant compatibility issues as many apps refuse to run on these non-standard systems. Graphene OS has criticized Google's approach to device attestation as flawed and incomplete, claiming that the requirements for Play Integrity compliance are often ignored. This has led to frustrations within the community, especially as popular apps like Authy have stopped functioning on Graphene OS due to these restrictions. The Graphene OS team has indicated that if Google does not allow them to pass Play Integrity checks, they may pursue legal action, having already begun discussions with regulators interested in the matter. The situation highlights the ongoing struggle for custom ROMs to gain recognition and support within the Android ecosystem, raising questions about the future of software compatibility and user choice in mobile operating systems.

- Tensions are rising between custom ROMs and Google over app compatibility issues.

- Graphene OS is prepared to take legal action if Google does not extend Play Integrity support.

- Many apps, including Authy, refuse to run on custom ROMs due to Play Integrity restrictions.

- The Graphene OS team criticizes Google's device attestation approach as flawed.

- Regulatory interest in the issue may lead to significant changes in the future.

Related

Google begs court for relief from Epic Games' Play Store demands

Google begs court for relief from Epic Games' Play Store demands

Google resists Epic Games' Play Store changes in court, citing high costs and security risks. Epic seeks third-party store access, porting support, and Google Play distribution. Ongoing legal battle over alleged Google Play monopoly.

Google Restricts RCS Messaging on Some Android Devices

Google Restricts RCS Messaging on Some Android Devices

Google restricts RCS messaging on certain Android devices like rooted ones. Users criticize the move, citing communication limitations. Google defends the action for spam prevention and security. Despite workarounds, affected users face challenges. This reflects Google's tighter control trend, akin to Apple. The competition between Android and iPhone, focusing on AI, may impact user preferences.

Ask HN: Concern over Chinese Software?

Ask HN: Concern over Chinese Software?

Concerns about Chinese software are rising due to U.S.-China tensions, CCP influence, and privacy issues. The author highlights challenges in avoiding Chinese products and seeks strategies to mitigate risks.

Loss of popular 2FA tool puts security-minded GrapheneOS in a paradox

Loss of popular 2FA tool puts security-minded GrapheneOS in a paradox

GrapheneOS faces challenges after Authy became incompatible, highlighting issues with Google's Play Integrity requirements. Ongoing discussions aim for compatibility, but legal action against Google may occur if exclusion continues.

Breaking up Google would offer a chance to remodel the web

Breaking up Google would offer a chance to remodel the web

The antitrust ruling against Google reveals its illegal monopoly, hindering competition. Alternatives exist but struggle. A post-Google internet aims for user privacy and diverse, non-invasive services.

Link Icon 2 comments
By @Sayrus - 5 months
Since the link is a bit hidden within the article, here is the relevant thread on Graphene's Mastodon instance: https://grapheneos.social/@GrapheneOS/112878067304840664
By @486sx33 - 5 months
You could probably make the case that googles retarded “open source” android isn’t at all, violates the GPL and, separately, initiate an anti trust lawsuit purely on the way that play store API killed blackberry