August 30th, 2024

Einstein's Other Theory of Everything

Einstein aimed to unify physical phenomena through spacetime but failed to derive matter from it. Hossenfelder suggests revisiting his ideas, which may hold relevance in contemporary physics discussions.

Read original articleLink Icon
Einstein's Other Theory of Everything

Einstein's pursuit of a unified field theory aimed to explain all physical phenomena, including matter and energy, as manifestations of spacetime. After developing general relativity in 1915, he sought to extend this framework to incorporate electromagnetism and other forces. Despite his efforts, including several papers from 1919 to 1925, he concluded that his attempts to derive matter from spacetime were unsuccessful. He introduced concepts like the Einstein-Rosen bridge, which he initially viewed as a representation of elementary particles, but later abandoned this idea due to inconsistencies with known particle sizes. Einstein's later work on tele-parallelism, which suggested that matter's properties could be encoded in spacetime relations, did not gain traction after his death, especially as new forces were discovered. Although some aspects of his original theory have been revisited in modern physics, the notion that matter is fundamentally a form of spacetime has largely been overlooked. The author, Sabine Hossenfelder, argues for the importance of revisiting Einstein's ideas, emphasizing their potential relevance in contemporary physics discussions.

- Einstein sought a unified theory to explain matter and energy as deformations of spacetime.

- His attempts to derive matter from spacetime were ultimately unsuccessful.

- The Einstein-Rosen bridge was initially thought to represent elementary particles but was later deemed inconsistent.

- Einstein's tele-parallelism approach to unification was not pursued after his death.

- Hossenfelder advocates for revisiting Einstein's original ideas in modern physics.

Related

Einstein and his peers were 'irrationally resistant' to black holes

Einstein and his peers were 'irrationally resistant' to black holes

Physicists, including Einstein, initially resisted the concept of black holes due to their strangeness and implications of singularities. Despite early skepticism, the existence of black holes has been confirmed, reshaping cosmic understanding.

Einstein and his peers were 'irrationally resistant' to black holes

Einstein and his peers were 'irrationally resistant' to black holes

Albert Einstein and peers initially resisted black hole concepts. Despite theoretical roots dating back a century, acceptance came in the 1960s with observational support. Einstein's work laid the foundation, but reluctance persisted due to clashes between evidence and personal beliefs.

Physicists: Tachyons can be reconciled with the special theory of relativity

Physicists: Tachyons can be reconciled with the special theory of relativity

Physicists propose a new view on tachyons, suggesting they enhance understanding of causal structures in relativity. Research introduces quantum entanglement between past and future, speculating on tachyons' role in matter formation.

Susskind: String Theory Is Not the Theory of the Real World

Susskind: String Theory Is Not the Theory of the Real World

Lenny Susskind expressed skepticism about string theory, stating it doesn't explain the real world, criticized oversimplified beliefs about supersymmetry, and emphasized responsible communication and uncertainty in theoretical physics' future.

The Geometric Tool That Solved Einstein's Relativity Problem

The Geometric Tool That Solved Einstein's Relativity Problem

Tensors are vital in Einstein's theory of relativity, enabling the description of gravity through space-time geometry. They are widely used in physics, computer science, and biology for complex relationships.

Link Icon 1 comments
By @taylodl - 8 months
Spacetime is a mathematical model that Einstein used to derive his field equations. Philosophically speaking, we are reminded to not confuse the model with reality. Even Einstein reminded us of that, even in regard to curved spacetime.

WRT to particles, we now model them as excitations of a quantum field. Quantum Field Theory, or QFT, is our most recent quantum theory and is the theory the Standard Model is based on. As such, it's enjoyed phenomenal success.