September 5th, 2024

FTC urged to make smart devices say how long they will be supported

Consumer advocacy groups are urging the FTC to establish guidelines for smart device support duration, addressing issues like "software tethering" that lead to feature removals and diminished device value.

Read original articleLink Icon
FTC urged to make smart devices say how long they will be supported

Consumer advocacy groups are urging the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to establish clear guidelines regarding the support duration for smart devices. In a letter addressed to FTC officials, representatives from 17 organizations, including Consumer Reports and iFixit, highlighted issues related to "software tethering," where device functionality is dependent on a manufacturer's servers. This practice has led to sudden feature removals and bricking of devices, causing frustration among consumers. The letter describes these actions as "unfair and deceptive," likening the gradual loss of functionality to "death by a thousand cuts." Examples cited include Peloton's activation fee for secondhand equipment and Oral-B toothbrushes losing Alexa compatibility. The groups argue that such practices diminish the value of purchased devices and hinder consumer ownership. They propose that the FTC require manufacturers to disclose a guaranteed minimum support period for their products, including security updates and functionality assurances. This guidance could help consumers make informed purchasing decisions regarding smart gadgets.

- Advocacy groups are pushing the FTC for clearer guidelines on smart device support.

- "Software tethering" practices are leading to sudden feature removals and device bricking.

- The letter compares the gradual loss of functionality to "death by a thousand cuts."

- Proposed FTC guidelines would require manufacturers to disclose minimum support durations.

- The initiative aims to enhance consumer rights and device ownership clarity.

Related

FTC Warns Companies to Stop Warranty Practices Harming Consumers Right to Repair

FTC Warns Companies to Stop Warranty Practices Harming Consumers Right to Repair

The FTC issued warning letters to companies for warranty practices potentially violating consumer rights. Concerns include restrictions on repair options and warranty void stickers. Companies must comply within 30 days to avoid enforcement actions.

US Government wants to make it easier for you to click the 'unsubscribe' button

US Government wants to make it easier for you to click the 'unsubscribe' button

The U.S. government is launching the "Time Is Money" initiative to simplify subscription cancellations, involving the FCC and FTC in creating regulations, despite some business opposition regarding pricing structures.

Canceling subscriptions should be as easy as signing up – proposed federal rule

Canceling subscriptions should be as easy as signing up – proposed federal rule

The Biden administration proposed regulations to simplify subscription cancellations, requiring minimal effort for consumers. This initiative targets various industries and aims to enhance consumer protections amid rising costs.

US wants to make it easier for you to click the 'unsubscribe' button

US wants to make it easier for you to click the 'unsubscribe' button

The U.S. government is launching the "Time Is Money" initiative to simplify subscription cancellations, involving multiple agencies to enhance consumer protection and address hidden fees, despite some business opposition.

With Power Comes Great Responsibility Platforms Want to Be Utilities (2021)

With Power Comes Great Responsibility Platforms Want to Be Utilities (2021)

Tech giants have created user dependency through opaque account termination processes and laws favoring corporate interests. Advocates seek transparency in moderation and "information fiduciary" rules to protect consumer rights.

Link Icon 4 comments
By @willcipriano - 5 months
If the FTC issued a statement that said any support windows that aren't on the box will be assumed to be forever, I could imagine that being used in court to argue that a reasonable person would assume that it is forever, given the government said it was.
By @dopylitty - 5 months
Countdown until a Texas judge with stock in a corporation decides not only that the FTC can’t issue such statements but that consumers should be forced to buy whatever product the corporation is selling.
By @z3c0 - 5 months
Focusing on support windows seems to be putting the symptom over the cause. Why not instead focus on the practices that are attempting to gouge customers on the secondhand market, e.g. Pelotons used equipment activation fee?