Wisdom of Kandiaronk–Indigenous Critique, Myth of Progress and Birth of the Left
The article discusses how Kandiaronk's critiques influenced Enlightenment thinkers on social inequality, arguing that Indigenous perspectives shaped Western thought and challenging the narrative of progress as a conservative response.
Read original article
The article "The Wisdom of Kandiaronk" by Christophe Petit and David Graeber explores the influence of Indigenous critiques, particularly from the figure of Kandiaronk, on Enlightenment thinkers and the development of leftist thought. It argues that the foundational texts of the Enlightenment, including Rousseau's writings on social inequality, were significantly shaped by Native American perspectives. The authors contend that the prevailing narrative of progress, which justifies social inequality as a necessary consequence of technological advancement, is a conservative reaction against these Indigenous critiques. They highlight that the fascination with social inequality emerged during a period when Europe was integrating into a global economy, leading to exposure to diverse ideas from other cultures. The text challenges the notion that Enlightenment ideas were solely the product of individual thinkers, suggesting instead that they were influenced by broader discussions, including those with Native Americans. The authors call for a reevaluation of how these interactions are understood, emphasizing that Indigenous voices played a crucial role in shaping Western thought on liberty and equality.
- Kandiaronk's critiques influenced Enlightenment thinkers, particularly regarding social inequality.
- The narrative of progress is portrayed as a conservative response to Indigenous critiques.
- The fascination with social inequality arose during Europe's integration into a global economy.
- Enlightenment ideas were shaped by broader cultural exchanges, not just individual thinkers.
- The article calls for a reevaluation of the impact of Indigenous perspectives on Western thought.
Related
Diagonalism, the Cosmic Right and the Conspiracy Smoothie
The concept of "Diagonalism" explores left-to-far-right shifts, challenging labels, blending spiritual beliefs, and rejecting mainstream ideologies. Figures like Naomi Wolf and Russell Brand are highlighted. Global diagonal movements show diverse denialist views, hindering societal progress amid crises.
A revolution in archaeology is transforming our picture of past populations
An archaeological revolution challenges views on empires and tribes, revealing violence in empires and sophistication in tribes. New research prompts reconsideration of historical narratives for a more equitable future.
The Myth of the Noble Savage
The "noble savage" concept, often linked to Rousseau, is challenged by anthropologist Ter Ellingson, who argues it misrepresents Indigenous peoples' relationship with nature and oversimplifies ecological narratives.
The Vital Necessity of Old Books (2023)
Joel J. Miller defends reading ancient texts, arguing they provide cognitive diversity, challenge modern biases, and foster critical thinking, essential for innovation and understanding history in contemporary discourse.
The Silicon Valley Canon: On the Paıdeía of the American Tech Elite
The article contrasts the intellectual cultures of Washington D.C. and Silicon Valley, highlighting Silicon Valley's preference for generalist knowledge, action, and diverse ideas over Washington's specialized expertise and utilitarian approach.
0 commentsRelated
Diagonalism, the Cosmic Right and the Conspiracy Smoothie
The concept of "Diagonalism" explores left-to-far-right shifts, challenging labels, blending spiritual beliefs, and rejecting mainstream ideologies. Figures like Naomi Wolf and Russell Brand are highlighted. Global diagonal movements show diverse denialist views, hindering societal progress amid crises.
A revolution in archaeology is transforming our picture of past populations
An archaeological revolution challenges views on empires and tribes, revealing violence in empires and sophistication in tribes. New research prompts reconsideration of historical narratives for a more equitable future.
The Myth of the Noble Savage
The "noble savage" concept, often linked to Rousseau, is challenged by anthropologist Ter Ellingson, who argues it misrepresents Indigenous peoples' relationship with nature and oversimplifies ecological narratives.
The Vital Necessity of Old Books (2023)
Joel J. Miller defends reading ancient texts, arguing they provide cognitive diversity, challenge modern biases, and foster critical thinking, essential for innovation and understanding history in contemporary discourse.
The Silicon Valley Canon: On the Paıdeía of the American Tech Elite
The article contrasts the intellectual cultures of Washington D.C. and Silicon Valley, highlighting Silicon Valley's preference for generalist knowledge, action, and diverse ideas over Washington's specialized expertise and utilitarian approach.