Against the Cultural Christianity Argument
The article critiques the "cultural Christianity" argument, advocating for modern atheists to create a new cultural framework instead of supporting outdated ideologies, emphasizing integrity over pragmatic falsehoods.
Read original article
The article critiques the "cultural Christianity" argument, which posits that atheists should support a Christian society for the sake of cultural benefits, even if they do not personally believe. The author, identifying as mostly atheist, acknowledges a decline in cultural aesthetics and expresses concern over modern societal trends. However, they argue against the notion that a return to Christianity is necessary for a flourishing society, pointing out that both Christianity and liberalism have historically faced degeneration into modernism and postmodernism. The author highlights that various cultures, including those rooted in Christianity, have succumbed to modernity, suggesting that advocating for a return to past norms is futile. Instead, they propose that modern atheists should seek to create a new cultural framework rather than cling to outdated ideologies. The author emphasizes the importance of integrity in this search, rejecting the idea of supporting falsehoods for pragmatic reasons.
- The "cultural Christianity" argument suggests atheists should support Christian culture for societal benefits.
- The author critiques this view, noting that both Christianity and liberalism have historically deteriorated into modernism.
- They argue that advocating for a return to past cultural norms is ineffective.
- The author calls for the creation of a new cultural framework by modern atheists.
- Integrity in belief is emphasized over pragmatic support for outdated ideologies.
Related
Why harmony with nature is a myth
The article critiques the myth of harmony with nature, advocating for human mastery and management. It promotes ecomodernism, emphasizing ambitious projects that enhance human life while acknowledging nature's indifference.
The Vital Necessity of Old Books (2023)
Joel J. Miller defends reading ancient texts, arguing they provide cognitive diversity, challenge modern biases, and foster critical thinking, essential for innovation and understanding history in contemporary discourse.
Our New Religion Isn't Enough
The article examines therapy culture's rise as a substitute for religion among youth, highlighting self-obsession, increasing mental health issues, and the need for moral guidance and community connections.
The Illusion of a Pagan West
The West is shifting from Christianity to neo-paganism, retaining Christian-derived values like human rights. This indicates a redefinition of spirituality rather than an abandonment of it.
Only the truly privileged can be cultural relativists
Josephine Bartosch critiques cultural relativism as a privilege of advanced societies, arguing that sanitizing history in museums obscures oppression and that judging cultures can highlight moral advancements, especially regarding women's rights.
2 comments(is there anyone outside the blogosphere making this argument?)
Related
Why harmony with nature is a myth
The article critiques the myth of harmony with nature, advocating for human mastery and management. It promotes ecomodernism, emphasizing ambitious projects that enhance human life while acknowledging nature's indifference.
The Vital Necessity of Old Books (2023)
Joel J. Miller defends reading ancient texts, arguing they provide cognitive diversity, challenge modern biases, and foster critical thinking, essential for innovation and understanding history in contemporary discourse.
Our New Religion Isn't Enough
The article examines therapy culture's rise as a substitute for religion among youth, highlighting self-obsession, increasing mental health issues, and the need for moral guidance and community connections.
The Illusion of a Pagan West
The West is shifting from Christianity to neo-paganism, retaining Christian-derived values like human rights. This indicates a redefinition of spirituality rather than an abandonment of it.
Only the truly privileged can be cultural relativists
Josephine Bartosch critiques cultural relativism as a privilege of advanced societies, arguing that sanitizing history in museums obscures oppression and that judging cultures can highlight moral advancements, especially regarding women's rights.