1+1=2 (2006)
The discussion highlights the historical significance of Whitehead and Russell's "Principia Mathematica," noting its lengthy proof of 1+1=2 and the evolution of mathematical notation and logic since its publication.
Read original articleThe discussion revolves around the historical and mathematical significance of Whitehead and Russell's "Principia Mathematica," particularly its proof that 1+1=2. The work, published around 1910, is noted for its extensive length and complexity, taking a thousand pages to establish foundational mathematical concepts, including the simple arithmetic of addition. The author highlights how the notation and techniques used in the book are outdated compared to modern mathematical practices. For instance, the authors lacked the concept of ordered pairs, which simplifies many proofs today. The text also critiques the redundancy in the work, where similar concepts are repeated due to the authors' limited understanding of logical structures at the time. The proof of 1+1=2 is presented as a culmination of earlier theorems, demonstrating the evolution of mathematical logic and notation. The author suggests that contemporary mathematics would approach these concepts more efficiently, thanks to advancements in understanding sets and relations. Overall, the piece serves as both a historical reflection on mathematical logic and a commentary on the evolution of mathematical notation and proof techniques.
- "Principia Mathematica" took a thousand pages to prove basic arithmetic.
- The work reflects early 20th-century mathematical logic, which has since evolved.
- Redundancies in the text highlight the authors' limited techniques at the time.
- Modern mathematics simplifies proofs using concepts like ordered pairs.
- The proof of 1+1=2 illustrates the foundational nature of set theory in mathematics.
Related
A Proof of Proof by Infinite Descent
The text explores proof by infinite descent in mathematical reasoning, using the irrationality of \(\sqrt{2}\) as an example. It discusses induction, well-foundedness, and the Principle of Infinite Descent for mathematical proofs.
A mathematical thought experiment for accepting the continuum hypothesis
The article explores the theoretical implications of considering the continuum hypothesis a fundamental axiom in mathematics, potentially impacting mathematical reasoning and structures. Alternative foundational schemes and implications of historical developments are discussed.
Math is running out of problems
Mathematics faces a decline in engaging problems, emphasizing complexity and specialization. Advocates propose prioritizing simplicity and elegance over quantity in research to maintain relevance and impact.
Physics is unreasonably good at creating new math
Recent trends show physics driving advancements in mathematics, with physicists exploring concepts freely. String theory connects diverse mathematical fields, reflecting a deep relationship rooted in human cognition and natural phenomena.
One Plus One Equals Two (2006)
The discussion highlights the historical and mathematical significance of "Principia Mathematica," noting its complex proof of 1+1=2 and how modern mathematics has streamlined such proofs through advancements in logic and notation.
Related
A Proof of Proof by Infinite Descent
The text explores proof by infinite descent in mathematical reasoning, using the irrationality of \(\sqrt{2}\) as an example. It discusses induction, well-foundedness, and the Principle of Infinite Descent for mathematical proofs.
A mathematical thought experiment for accepting the continuum hypothesis
The article explores the theoretical implications of considering the continuum hypothesis a fundamental axiom in mathematics, potentially impacting mathematical reasoning and structures. Alternative foundational schemes and implications of historical developments are discussed.
Math is running out of problems
Mathematics faces a decline in engaging problems, emphasizing complexity and specialization. Advocates propose prioritizing simplicity and elegance over quantity in research to maintain relevance and impact.
Physics is unreasonably good at creating new math
Recent trends show physics driving advancements in mathematics, with physicists exploring concepts freely. String theory connects diverse mathematical fields, reflecting a deep relationship rooted in human cognition and natural phenomena.
One Plus One Equals Two (2006)
The discussion highlights the historical and mathematical significance of "Principia Mathematica," noting its complex proof of 1+1=2 and how modern mathematics has streamlined such proofs through advancements in logic and notation.