India issues notice to Wikipedia over concerns of bias
India's Ministry of Information and Broadcasting has questioned Wikipedia's neutrality, citing bias and inaccuracies, following a Delhi High Court case that criticized its editing model and threatened suspension.
Read original articleIndia's Ministry of Information and Broadcasting has issued a notice to Wikipedia, questioning its status as a neutral intermediary and raising concerns about editorial bias and inaccuracies. This action follows a defamation case in the Delhi High Court, where judges criticized Wikipedia's open editing model as potentially harmful and threatened to suspend its operations in India. The court is currently addressing a case brought by Asian News International, which seeks to identify contributors who allegedly labeled the agency as a government propaganda tool. Justice Navin Chawla dismissed Wikipedia's request for more time to respond, emphasizing compliance with Indian regulations. Wikipedia argues that its volunteer editors follow established policies for content verification, but this defense is under scrutiny. Nikhil Pahwa, a technology policy expert, has questioned the legal basis for the government's actions, suggesting that India's IT law should determine platform status based on functionality rather than the number of editors. Wikimedia, the organization behind Wikipedia, has not yet commented on the situation.
- India questions Wikipedia's status as a neutral intermediary.
- Concerns raised about bias and inaccuracies in Wikipedia's content.
- Delhi High Court criticized Wikipedia's open editing feature.
- Wikipedia faces potential suspension of operations in India.
- Legal experts challenge the government's basis for its actions.
Related
Wikipedia summoned by Delhi High Court over ANI defamation allegations
The Delhi High Court summons Wikipedia over a defamation suit by ANI, alleging defamatory edits on its page. Court acknowledges concerns, schedules next hearing for August 20 to examine claims. ANI disputes statements on Wikipedia.
In a first, Wikipedia takes down article globally after Delhi HC order
Wikipedia removed an article following a Delhi High Court order, marking a global first. The court ruled it interfered with ongoing proceedings in a defamation case against Wikimedia by ANI.
Wikipedia article blocked worldwide by Delhi high court
The Wikimedia Foundation suspended access to a page due to a Delhi High Court directive, while exploring legal options and reaffirming its commitment to knowledge as a fundamental human right.
Wikipedia agrees to share details with Delhi Court about users who made edits
Wikipedia will provide the Delhi High Court with user information related to edits on ANI's page, maintaining confidentiality. The defamation case against Wikipedia by ANI remains pending, with ongoing court concerns.
Wikipedia Offers to Reveal User Identities in Sealed Covers in ANI Case
Wikipedia will provide user data to the Delhi High Court regarding edits to the ANI page, maintaining confidentiality. The case addresses defamation claims and the responsibilities of online intermediaries.
Related
Wikipedia summoned by Delhi High Court over ANI defamation allegations
The Delhi High Court summons Wikipedia over a defamation suit by ANI, alleging defamatory edits on its page. Court acknowledges concerns, schedules next hearing for August 20 to examine claims. ANI disputes statements on Wikipedia.
In a first, Wikipedia takes down article globally after Delhi HC order
Wikipedia removed an article following a Delhi High Court order, marking a global first. The court ruled it interfered with ongoing proceedings in a defamation case against Wikimedia by ANI.
Wikipedia article blocked worldwide by Delhi high court
The Wikimedia Foundation suspended access to a page due to a Delhi High Court directive, while exploring legal options and reaffirming its commitment to knowledge as a fundamental human right.
Wikipedia agrees to share details with Delhi Court about users who made edits
Wikipedia will provide the Delhi High Court with user information related to edits on ANI's page, maintaining confidentiality. The defamation case against Wikipedia by ANI remains pending, with ongoing court concerns.
Wikipedia Offers to Reveal User Identities in Sealed Covers in ANI Case
Wikipedia will provide user data to the Delhi High Court regarding edits to the ANI page, maintaining confidentiality. The case addresses defamation claims and the responsibilities of online intermediaries.