Bluesky and Enshittification
Cory Doctorow critiques social media "enshittification," emphasizing user freedom and the need for federated features. He admires Bluesky's advancements but remains cautious due to potential platform dependency.
Read original articleCory Doctorow discusses the concept of "enshittification" in relation to social media platforms, particularly Bluesky. He expresses admiration for Bluesky's technical advancements in moderation and ranking but remains hesitant to join due to concerns about platform dependency. Doctorow reflects on past experiences with platforms that initially promised user-centric values but ultimately compromised their integrity under pressure from investors. He emphasizes that enshittification occurs when platforms can exploit user loyalty without fear of losing their audience, leading to a decline in service quality. To counter this, he advocates for systems that allow users to easily switch platforms, thereby imposing costs on service owners who might consider compromising user experience. Doctorow highlights the importance of federation, as seen in platforms like Mastodon, which enables users to migrate without significant barriers. He notes that while Bluesky has potential, it currently lacks the necessary federated features to ensure user freedom and trust. Until such features are implemented, Doctorow remains committed to his principle of avoiding platforms that could trap him, viewing this as a protective measure against future compromises.
- Doctorow critiques the risk of "enshittification" in social media platforms.
- He values user freedom and the ability to switch platforms without penalties.
- Federation is essential for maintaining user trust and service integrity.
- Bluesky's current lack of federated features raises concerns for potential users.
- Doctorow's personal rule is to avoid platforms that could lead to dependency.
Related
With Bluesky, the social media echo chamber is back in vogue
Bluesky is gaining traction as users leave X, particularly progressives in the UK. However, it faces criticism for fostering echo chambers, raising concerns about the viability of inclusive digital discourse.
Fedi Is for Losers
The article examines the Fediverse's appeal to those leaving Twitter, highlighting its community spirit but criticizing its lack of strategic engagement with societal issues and activism compared to Twitter and Bluesky.
Cory Doctorow With a Plan to Halt the Internet's Enshittification
Cory Doctorow's keynote at Supercon 2023 focused on combating "enshittification" of the internet through stronger antitrust laws, interoperability, and privacy protections, advocating for a more equitable digital landscape.
Bluesky's Alternate Approach to Feeds Is One of Its Best Features
Bluesky is a new social media platform featuring a chronological "Following" feed and customizable options, allowing users to create, share, and personalize their content experience, contrasting with traditional models.
Why Bluesky not adding the federation systems
Cory Doctorow discusses "enshittification" in social media, praising Bluesky's moderation but wary of control issues. He emphasizes user agency, easy platform switching, and critiques Bluesky's lack of a federated structure.
Related
With Bluesky, the social media echo chamber is back in vogue
Bluesky is gaining traction as users leave X, particularly progressives in the UK. However, it faces criticism for fostering echo chambers, raising concerns about the viability of inclusive digital discourse.
Fedi Is for Losers
The article examines the Fediverse's appeal to those leaving Twitter, highlighting its community spirit but criticizing its lack of strategic engagement with societal issues and activism compared to Twitter and Bluesky.
Cory Doctorow With a Plan to Halt the Internet's Enshittification
Cory Doctorow's keynote at Supercon 2023 focused on combating "enshittification" of the internet through stronger antitrust laws, interoperability, and privacy protections, advocating for a more equitable digital landscape.
Bluesky's Alternate Approach to Feeds Is One of Its Best Features
Bluesky is a new social media platform featuring a chronological "Following" feed and customizable options, allowing users to create, share, and personalize their content experience, contrasting with traditional models.
Why Bluesky not adding the federation systems
Cory Doctorow discusses "enshittification" in social media, praising Bluesky's moderation but wary of control issues. He emphasizes user agency, easy platform switching, and critiques Bluesky's lack of a federated structure.