Dark Incentives: Your app doesn't love you (2022)
Modern applications prioritize profit over user experience, compromising user autonomy. Subscription models restrict alternatives, while free apps often exploit users, reflecting corporate structures that overshadow user-centric design.
Read original articleModern applications often operate under "dark incentives," which prioritize profit over user experience. Neil Panchal's critique of Spotify highlights how contemporary app designs can limit user autonomy, steering behavior to maximize monetization rather than enhancing user satisfaction. Unlike the straightforward functionality of older platforms like iTunes, many apps today, including Spotify and Reddit, manipulate user interactions to control outcomes. This design philosophy is particularly evident in subscription-based models, where companies like Discord restrict alternative clients to protect their profit margins. The more "free" an app is, the more it tends to exploit users, as seen with Reddit's aggressive push towards its app, which is designed to gather more data and control user engagement. Despite the potential for apps to foster positive user relationships, the corporate structures behind them often prioritize profit over genuine user care, leading to a disconnect between user needs and app functionality. Ultimately, while apps can be designed with user love in mind, the current landscape often reflects a lack of this consideration, driven by the impersonal nature of large corporations.
- Modern apps often prioritize profit over user experience.
- User autonomy is frequently compromised by app design.
- Subscription models can lead to restrictions on alternative clients.
- Free apps tend to exploit users more than paid ones.
- Corporate structures often overshadow the potential for user-centric design.
Related
FTC finds 'dark patterns' used by a majority of subscription apps and websites
The FTC study reveals most subscription apps and websites employ manipulative "dark patterns" affecting user privacy and behavior. Findings prompt increased FTC scrutiny on consumer fraud amid ongoing industry deception concerns.
I Quit Spotify
The author quit Spotify due to frustrations with its updated interface, which prioritizes playlists over albums, leading to user alienation. They switched to Apple Music for a better experience.
Apple vs. the "Free Market"
Apple's 30% App Store fee impacts creators' revenues, distorts markets, and limits competition. Its DMCA interpretation enforces restrictive device rules, raising concerns about consumer rights and smaller businesses' viability.
Please Don't Make Me Download Another App
The surge in smartphone applications has complicated daily tasks, diminishing their initial convenience and leading to user frustration. This trend is expected to continue, embedding apps deeper into everyday life.
Freedom to run 3rd party clients
Client freedom has decreased since the 1990s due to closed protocols on platforms like Twitter. Users face risks with third-party clients, and the author advocates for improved features and user experience.
Related
FTC finds 'dark patterns' used by a majority of subscription apps and websites
The FTC study reveals most subscription apps and websites employ manipulative "dark patterns" affecting user privacy and behavior. Findings prompt increased FTC scrutiny on consumer fraud amid ongoing industry deception concerns.
I Quit Spotify
The author quit Spotify due to frustrations with its updated interface, which prioritizes playlists over albums, leading to user alienation. They switched to Apple Music for a better experience.
Apple vs. the "Free Market"
Apple's 30% App Store fee impacts creators' revenues, distorts markets, and limits competition. Its DMCA interpretation enforces restrictive device rules, raising concerns about consumer rights and smaller businesses' viability.
Please Don't Make Me Download Another App
The surge in smartphone applications has complicated daily tasks, diminishing their initial convenience and leading to user frustration. This trend is expected to continue, embedding apps deeper into everyday life.
Freedom to run 3rd party clients
Client freedom has decreased since the 1990s due to closed protocols on platforms like Twitter. Users face risks with third-party clients, and the author advocates for improved features and user experience.