June 25th, 2024

Stalin, Eisenstein, Walt Disney and Ivan the Terrible (1992)

Stalin disapproved Eisenstein's Ivan the Terrible film due to its portrayal of a tyrant, facing suppression until after Stalin's death. Eisenstein admired Disney's animation despite ideological differences, highlighting artistic challenges under Soviet censorship.

Read original articleLink Icon
Stalin, Eisenstein, Walt Disney and Ivan the Terrible (1992)

The article discusses the relationship between Stalin, Walt Disney, Eisenstein, and Ivan the Terrible in the context of filmmaking. Eisenstein's ambitious project on Ivan the Terrible faced Stalin's disapproval due to its depiction of a tyrannical ruler, leading to its suppression until after Stalin's death. Eisenstein's admiration for Disney's animation techniques is highlighted, with parallels drawn between their styles in the imagery of Ivan the Terrible. Despite ideological differences, Eisenstein praised Disney for his ability to bring joy to audiences and his innovative animation methods. The article also delves into Stalin's control over Soviet cinema, with key figures like Andrey Zhdanov enforcing strict guidelines on artistic content. The Party leadership's scrutiny of films like Ivan the Terrible Part II reflects the intense censorship and pressure faced by filmmakers in the Soviet Union. The article sheds light on the complex dynamics between art, politics, and censorship during this period, emphasizing the challenges faced by filmmakers striving for creative expression under authoritarian regimes.

Related

How Cathode Ray Tubes Work. [video]

How Cathode Ray Tubes Work. [video]

The video explores CRT display technology, dominant for 70 years before LCDs rose. CRTs use electrons on phosphorus screens, guided by electromagnets. Evolution from B&W to color displays is discussed.

No Matter What They Tell You, It's a People Problem (2008)

No Matter What They Tell You, It's a People Problem (2008)

The article emphasizes the crucial role of people in software development, citing teamwork, communication, and problem-solving skills as key factors for project success. It highlights the importance of job satisfaction and team cohesion, underlining the significance of positive personal relationships within development teams.

The case for not sanitising fairy tales

The case for not sanitising fairy tales

Haley Stewart argues against sanitizing fairy tales for children, emphasizing their role in teaching about evil and danger. She questions the benefits of shielding children from dark themes, advocating for the value of fairy tales in navigating life's complexities.

The Lost Art of Fan-Made Anime 'Trollsubs' (2020)

The Lost Art of Fan-Made Anime 'Trollsubs' (2020)

The article explores fan-made anime subtitles by groups like [gg] and CoalGuys, known for localized and unconventional translations challenging industry norms and emphasizing free content over official translations.

Why American tech companies need to help build AI weaponry

Why American tech companies need to help build AI weaponry

U.S. tech companies play a crucial role in AI weaponry development for future warfare. Authors stress military supremacy, ethical considerations, and urge societal debate on military force and AI weaponry. Tech industry faces resistance over military projects.

Link Icon 12 comments
By @Eisenstein - 5 months
It shouldn't be too surprising that Eisenstein admired Disney's work.

For those that haven't seen it, I highly recommend watching Eisenstein's 'Strike'. An overlooked masterpiece which was the birth of the montage.

Here is a link (it is public domain):

* https://youtu.be/Yw6aMqBjGKQ?si=HRXpOYZZleeSkV4C

By @topherjaynes - 5 months
Oh wow this threw me back to film school. There is a great book by Ester Leslie called Hollywood Flatlands: Animation, Critical Theory and the Avant-Garde that walks through the overlap in animation and the avant-garde movement. It's very in-depth read if you liked this article
By @azangru - 5 months
A caption to a figure in the article reads "Georgi Molotov ... 'the great survivor', was one of Stalin's key enforcers for decades". Wasn't Molotov's name Vyacheslav? [0]

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vyacheslav_Molotov

By @vgel - 5 months
Reading the transcript of Stalin, Molotov, etc's conversation with Eisenstein was really interesting. Even if you disagree with their analysis and what they're doing, it's clear they know the period very well--it's hard to imagine modern politicians speaking on history like that.
By @The_Colonel - 5 months
It's an interesting facet of Stalin's personality that he was a big movie nerd. Many of his "parties" ended with binge-watching movies with other high level party members (who were pretty much forced to be there).
By @throw4847285 - 5 months
"Great artist admired other great artist." Not really breaking news. I think the work of Disney and his team of animators has long been recognized as brilliant. There's no need for the chip on the shoulder.

The idea of Eisenstein as a live action animator is very cool though. I've only seen Battleship Potemkin, but even from that I see what the writer of this piece means. It took an admirer of animation to think that creatively about editing, and to make the move from realism to something more/less.

Fun fact: my grandfather was a dyed in the wool commie, and he saw Battleship Potemkin probably 1,000 times. My grandmother could not understand how he could watch it over and over again, but even after one viewing, I get it. It's thrilling.

By @placebo - 5 months
"Eisenstein asked whether there were some more instructions regarding the film.

Stalin. I am not giving you instructions but expressing the viewer's opinion."

Yeah, right...