August 4th, 2024

Braid, Anniversary Edition 'Sold Like Dogs**T,' Developer Jonathan Blow Says

Jonathan Blow expressed disappointment over the poor sales of Braid: Anniversary Edition, stating it sold "horribly" and impacted his ability to hire staff. The game's future remains uncertain.

Read original articleLink Icon
Braid, Anniversary Edition 'Sold Like Dogs**T,' Developer Jonathan Blow Says

Jonathan Blow, the developer of the indie puzzle platformer Braid, has expressed disappointment over the sales performance of the recently released Braid: Anniversary Edition, stating it has sold "horribly." Despite the game's initial success in 2008, the remastered version, which features updated artwork, new puzzles, and commentary, has not met sales expectations since its launch in May 2024 across multiple platforms. Blow indicated that the poor sales have impacted his ability to employ staff full-time, stating, "we can't afford to pay anyone because the sales are bad." He described the game's sales as "utterly terrible" and noted that while releasing on various platforms made some difference, many of those platforms are now struggling. Blow also reflected on the challenges of promoting the game, suggesting that traditional marketing efforts like conventions and podcasts did not significantly boost its visibility. He speculated that there may have been little demand for a remaster of Braid, given that the original game remains playable and well-regarded. Blow's studio, Thekla, Inc., is reportedly working on several unannounced projects, including a VR game, but the future of the company appears uncertain due to the disappointing sales of Braid: Anniversary Edition.

Link Icon 6 comments
By @0xy - 7 months
He fell into the ultimate game developer bikeshedding trap of building not only his own engine, but his own programming language for some reason.

It's been over 8 years between releases, and all that time has been spent building a closed source programming language that allegedly speeds up game development.

Very few studios are capable of maintaining their own engine, none are capable of maintaining their own programming language. This is why, as an example, 343 imploded after one of their leads insisted on continuing with the 20 year old non-standard engine Slipspace. If they had their own programming language in addition to that, they never would've released anything.

By @gnabgib - 7 months
Discussion (45 points, 3 days ago, 106 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41121718
By @01HNNWZ0MV43FF - 7 months
> Did you buy Braid, Anniversary Edition? Tell us why in the comments

No, because I already own Braid.

Like how the toughest competition for Windows is not desktop Linux, it's pirated Windows.

By @cedws - 7 months
Tangential but I recently played The Witness and found it incredible.

It is a bit shocking that they’ve blown through so much cash to develop their own engine/game, but I think they’ll be fine. It’s nearly ready to go, Jonathon is confident sounding enough he’ll be able to raise capital if he needs.

By @horns4lyfe - 7 months
Braid is an excellent game and a work of art, but it certainly didn’t need an anniversary edition.
By @justinclift - 7 months
> Did you buy Braid, Anniversary Edition? Tell us why in the comments

Nope. Never heard of it before, and it doesn't look interesting to me.