Disenshittify or Die
Cory Doctorow's talk at Defcon 32 discussed "enshittification," a cycle where digital platforms decline in quality as they prioritize profit over user experience, urging users to resist exploitative practices.
Read original articleCory Doctorow delivered a talk titled "Disenshittify or Die" at Defcon 32, addressing the concept of "enshittification," which describes the decline in quality of digital platforms as they prioritize profit over user experience. He argues that companies initially provide good services to attract users but later exploit them by locking them in and degrading the service to benefit business customers. This cycle consists of three phases: first, companies cater to users while locking them in; second, they begin to compromise user experience to please business clients; and finally, they exploit both users and businesses, retaining only minimal utility. Doctorow criticizes major tech companies like Google, Facebook, Amazon, and Apple for their practices that prioritize profit over user satisfaction, leading to a degraded internet experience. He emphasizes that even paying customers often find themselves treated as products, as companies manipulate services and pricing through algorithms and surveillance. The talk serves as a call to action for users to recognize and resist these exploitative practices in the digital landscape.
- Cory Doctorow's talk focuses on the concept of "enshittification" in digital platforms.
- The cycle of enshittification involves three phases: attracting users, exploiting them, and degrading services.
- Major tech companies are criticized for prioritizing profit over user experience.
- Paying customers are often still treated as products due to manipulative practices.
- Doctorow encourages users to recognize and resist exploitative digital practices.
Related
Our Users Deserve a Bill of Rights
The author critiques the tech industry's neglect of end users, advocating for a "User Bill of Rights" to ensure accountability and balance between innovation and stability in software development.
Computer Security Is a Political Struggle
The digital landscape is increasingly controlled by a few, leading to political struggles over technology. Cybersecurity issues reflect deeper political failures, necessitating a collective response to reclaim digital rights and security.
The Web We've (Never) Lost
Jan Vlnas' talk at PragueJS highlights the decline of mainstream web platforms, introducing the "peripheral web" as a vibrant alternative. He encourages exploring decentralized spaces and personal websites for creativity.
Why Technological Progress Is Now Reversing
The article discusses the disconnect between technological advancement and societal benefit, highlighting issues like user exploitation, lack of accountability, and the need for reevaluating technology's societal role.
With Power Comes Great Responsibility Platforms Want to Be Utilities (2021)
Tech giants have created user dependency through opaque account termination processes and laws favoring corporate interests. Advocates seek transparency in moderation and "information fiduciary" rules to protect consumer rights.
It was "free," which is impossible because software (especially usable software) is actually very expensive to create and services cost money to run. Since "free" is and always has been a lie, the market found all kinds of alternative ways to monetize. These are called "enshittification."
The concept is useful but I find his views on it oversimplified and one-sided to the point of being infantile. He avoids addressing the elephant in the room: the combination of users being price-anchored on "free" with the fact that software and services are anything but free. This dissonance guarantees a perverse market.
Related
Our Users Deserve a Bill of Rights
The author critiques the tech industry's neglect of end users, advocating for a "User Bill of Rights" to ensure accountability and balance between innovation and stability in software development.
Computer Security Is a Political Struggle
The digital landscape is increasingly controlled by a few, leading to political struggles over technology. Cybersecurity issues reflect deeper political failures, necessitating a collective response to reclaim digital rights and security.
The Web We've (Never) Lost
Jan Vlnas' talk at PragueJS highlights the decline of mainstream web platforms, introducing the "peripheral web" as a vibrant alternative. He encourages exploring decentralized spaces and personal websites for creativity.
Why Technological Progress Is Now Reversing
The article discusses the disconnect between technological advancement and societal benefit, highlighting issues like user exploitation, lack of accountability, and the need for reevaluating technology's societal role.
With Power Comes Great Responsibility Platforms Want to Be Utilities (2021)
Tech giants have created user dependency through opaque account termination processes and laws favoring corporate interests. Advocates seek transparency in moderation and "information fiduciary" rules to protect consumer rights.